Enforcement Ban System Wrongly Terminating Innocent Accounts

There’s a growing issue within Roblox’s moderation system known as “Enforcement Bans”, this type of ban occurs when an account is terminated and other unrelated accounts that have any form of shared data or connection with it such as IP addresses, device, billing info or email information are automatically flagged and permanently banned as well. This can happen with very limited contact as far as we the community know, such as:

Logging into Roblox on Public Wifi or shared network ( school, cafe, or hotel )
Using a family device or a shared PC
Having previously logged into an old account that was later terminated
Sharing billing methods, emails or phone numbers between accounts

Even if you had an older account that you just didn’t use in a couple of years, if that account was terminated for whatever reason, your affiliated accounts whether it be through email, phone number or just login history now have to suffer the consequences. And most of these terminations issued on these accounts in the first place are automated and not even human issued decisions, this is extremely unfair and honestly just corrupt to the millions of innocent people who spend hundreds of dollars to even thousands of dollars on this game. I myself am victim to this bug, and I think that its time that roblox realizes that they cant just get away with this anymore, you are a billion dollar company, you need to cater to the needs and expectations of your community, fix the AI sloppy moderation and give us a decent human support channel.

Many people, and I mean hundreds of people have reported dealing with this issue on countless social media websites such as reddit, discord, youtube and x, and everyday there are more and more complaints. Additionally Roblox provides little to no information when issuing these bans, essentially just giving you nothing to work off of, and if you appeal and they don’t like it, you can never appeal again per their TOS.

Expected behavior

Only accounts that directly violate Roblox’s Terms of Use should be moderated or terminated, unless there is concrete evidence that those are the same people and they are directly and purposely violating the TOS. ( These decisions should be Human not AI.. ) Innocent users should not be affected by another person’s enforcement action, especially when the connection is indirect or years old.

Roblox should review and improve the Enforcement Ban detection system to ensure it does not punish innocent users, some potential fixes include:

Manual Review
Differentiation between public/shared networks and private connections
Clearer communication and information given to users when these bans are issued ( What account caused it, why that account was banned, how you were connected to it, etc )
Better Support in general would also remedy this issue in some way

It’s extremely disappointing that a company of this scale would have these problems.

A private message is associated with this bug report

42 Likes

A lot of people are currently having the same issue: 22 of my accounts falsely terminated
Even one of my Discord server members got affected, potentially a ban wave that’s happening RN.

Also someone said that Roblox’s TOS stated that they could ban anyone for any reason.

10 Likes

The best thing we can do is attempt to spread awareness on the situation and hope Roblox staff respond with a fix.

8 Likes

I hope roblox unban innocent accounts fast we need to spread this everyone

8 Likes

I know about 3 people that got terminated by this.
this is a very weird and stupid thing to happen. Some of those people didn’t even have alternate accounts???

6 Likes

Bump.
Seen someone get banned the exact same way.

4 Likes

Bump. ROBLOX is making a huge error, and this could result in millions of accounts being permanently deleted for seemingly no reason.

2 Likes

Bump [3]. Roblox terminated all the accounts connected to one of my emails last night because in early 2022 I restored & fixed a lost showcase from early 2007 under an alt, and that game just so happened to have an official bed model uploaded by the Roblox account itself.

Every appeal I’ve made since has been either ghosted or rejected, and several other accounts of mine have been terminated since I contacted support. So annoying.

13 Likes

bumping this again.

My accounts have been falsely banned for this reason as well.
I had millions of robux on my main account, and it’s been terminated for no reason.
I used to work from Cafes near my house, and sometimes used the public Wifi.

I don’t understand roblox, we work years on our accounts and skills, helping roblox’s community grow, and in one day, we get betrayed.

This should really raise a red flag to every developer on this platform. Even if I’ll get my account back, I’m not sure if I’ll stay here for long, at least not until they fix this ongoing issue.

Not only that, much of my intellectual property (games, scripts etc) is on my accounts, saved via Roblox Studio.
I’ve had a framework that I’ve worked on for a year, terminated in an instance. Of course I have some snippets of that framework, but not the full updated version of it. Not sure what to do about it… I’m currently contacting a lawyer to resolve this, even if it means suing to get it back

3 Likes

I’ve not been a victim yet, but it pisses me off how hard this sites moderation STILL SUCKS despite the 19 years of its existence. According to companiesmarketcap, Roblox’s market cap is 87.64 BILLION, and they still can’t afford a semi-decent moderation system? Guess they are spending too much money on useless junk like that weird makeup feature that only a few people will likely use.

I hope Roblox addresses this and restores everyones accounts as soon as possible.

2 Likes

One of my co-developers (ID 21876044) on our project, Rails Unlimited, received this same kind of termination yesterday with a reason from April 2024. He has sent in an appeal already but has not heard back as of earlier today. They are away right now so I can’t confirm if anyone has gotten back to him yet.

2 Likes

If Roblox is trying to take their image seriously now they would have the integrity to address this…

Or they’ll just be radio silent about it and let people go through the roulette support system, leaving innocent players stuck going back and forth with another ai system that ultimately puts them into a loop until their 30 days are up just so they can say there’s nothing else they can do.

Sad age we live in where the players who literally make up the community have to fend for themselves now, but at this point community isn’t as valuable to them anymore than the young majority who give them the numbers their investors want to see, so I wouldn’t doubt we just seem expendable in their eyes now a days.

2 Likes

According to privacy laws (depending on your countries), roblox is obliged to present us the full data they collected on us. This includes the account linkage and reasons of the termination of our accounts.
Some countries have government organizations for consumers, and they can assist us with this, and in some cases, can impose financial penalties on roblox if they fail to provide us the information.

I’m still waiting for the appeal itself, but if I’ll get automatically rejected I’ll contact their privacy/legal team to request my data

2 Likes

I’ve seen many people being terminated with enforcement bans dating back to 2024. I don’t know what is going on the past few days.

2 Likes

yep thats most cases, my accounts have been terminated with a review date of November 15, 2024

2 Likes

This has happened to my friend’s account too. His brother got terminated for a pretty stupid reason (which is his brother’s fault entirely, he was being edgy) and caused my friend’s main account with over 1 millions value to be enforcement banned falsely. He emailed support, showing them proof of his account ownership and nothing has happened in the span of 30 days to appeal, they also ignored his tickets too. He is still considering doing an midr but it is just too time consuming (he has real life jobs) and unsure if that will get him to be unterminated because it been past a year now.

1 Like

imo they should limit it to a max of 7 days or use hardware ids instead of ips

4 Likes

The enforcement ban system was their stupidest idea ever. I’m appalled at whoever thought this was a good idea to implement THIS late into roblox’s life. They need to remove this atrocious system immediately.

4 Likes

My main account was also effected by this , along with several of my friends .The reason was from December last year. I don’t use any other accounts other then this one so this confused me.