To clarify, I consider rares as items with 100 or less copies and semi rares as 200 or less copies (will be based off what items are marked rare on Rolimon’s). Items are not currently listed in any particular order.
Rares:
Chair Racing Intern
The Fire Crown
Steampunkoneer
Headdress of Aken-Aten, the Sun King
Chronobonum: The Blessed Helm
Tasteful Top Hat
A Dark Presence
Crimsonwrath, Lord of Entropy
8-Bit Immortal Sword: The Pixel Maker
King of the Dark Crop
Collision Top Hat
ColdLika: Snowman
Real Ice Cold Stunnas
Ornate Back Katana of Illusion
Glorious Cyan Party Queen
Glorious Purple Party Queen
Immortal Sword: Shameless Scimitar
Rubywrath Dragon
Copper Steampunk Top Hat
Semi rares:
Disgraced Baroness of the Federation
Bombastic Clockwork Shades
Dual Illumina
Robber Baron Top Hat
Purple Ice Crown
Green Ice Crown
Helm of the Frozen North
Sapphire Laser Vision
Emerald Laser Vision
Crimson Laser Vision
Azurewrath: Lord of Destruction
Azurewrath: Lord of the Frost
Classic Hat Stack
W1NN3R
Brain Power Top Hat
Holly Jolly Top Hat
Green Laurel Wreath
Ghostfire Sword
Benthic Deephunter
Sinister Top Hat
Guitar Glasses
All Hallows Warrior
Crimson Double Threat
Telamon’s Foe Hammer
NVG360 Hawkeyes
Classical Glory
Azure Dragon’s Magic Slayer
Frost Guardian of the Frozen North
The Bull
Grim Glow
Illumivision Mystic
Masked Hood of the Lightning Striker
Lightning Orb
Mo’ horns Helmet
Fall Periastron Xi
Festive Periastron Chi
Joyful Periastron Epsilon
Beach Ball Head
Squid Overlord
Xanwood Crown
2011 New Year’s Top Hat
Transparent Icephones
Baron von Bot
Pieface Jellyfreckles
Musica Dominator
Bat Knight Bat Sword
Mr. Fancy Skeleton
Mr. Mountain
Skeleton King’s Face Mask
Snowflake Shutter Shades
Eyes of the Overworld
Wooly Bully
Crimsonwrath, Lord of the Magma
Oven Monster
Mardi Gras Sword
Horns of Frozenfaic
Immortal Sword: Burning Embrace
Bunny Ear Fedora
Portrait of a Hero Crossing the Delaware
Portrait of a Hero at ROBLOX HQ
Portrait of a Hero in the Alps
Legend of the Four Winds
Mighty Ruler of Dragon’s Fire
Pin-tastic Felt Cap
Nuclear Winter Icicle Gun
The Necrosapien Staff
Diademed Barbarian Prince
Lightweight Top Hat
Caveman Cloak
Mayor of Summer
Dark Warrior
Magical Mystery Hat
Bright Star Top Hat
Golden Chakram of the Sky Palace
Kronoboss
Sir Gideon, the Sinister
Ceremonial Guard of the Archduke of the Federation
Ceremonial Guard of the Duke of the Federation
Aer Draco
Ancalagon
Glaurung the Greedy
Lovestruck Robot
Alien Monarch
Halloween Beanie
Lightbulb
Green Galaxy Gaze
The Maker Fedora
Dark Magic Top Hat
Enchanted Ruler
Blue Hat of the Orient
Spec Zeta Biograft Energy Sword
Spec Chi Biograft Energy Sword
Golden Crown of Warlords
Ruby Crystal Circlet
Magenta Crystal Circlet
Emerald Crystal Circlet
Silicon Valley Shades
Korblox King
Crimson Destiny Turban
Red Rockstar Smile
Chaplin