Hello and I just made a new icon for a new halloween update in my game and I need your opinon on it. The Last Icon I made was like 1 - 2 months ago and I made a new Icon to start fresh.
This is the very first game Icon in my game: 
In this Icon I made it in Photoshop but many people said it was made on paint dot net because of it’s basicness, but it was back then I was inexperienced and haven’t been using Photoshop that much. Then after this, I started using Photoshop as my photo editing application so I can use it more in the future.
Yesterday, I made another Icon for my game again using Photoshop and I applied eveything that I have learned and I gathered all the criticism which the dev forum community gave me (I really appreciate it) and came up with this:
in this picture, I used many elements so I can enhance the logo, rather than before, I expremented and played with stuff in Photoshop, I used blending options and filters, I enhanced the text by adding a glow effect in it and to make it more interesting I browsed my pc to see if I have some images to go with the icon and I got this vector pumpkin:
not the original picture I used cuz I’m not in my real pc rn
and played with effects and turned it into this:
Now I like your creative criticism and feedbacks so I can use them for future icons
