[Feedback] Fireplace I made

Hello all,

I made this fireplace with tips from @OfficiallySpxro and I wanted you guys to give me feedback on it and rate it out of 10 please.

Fire
Fire 2

Thank you.

2 Likes

It is good. I just voted 3 because I could probably build it myself rather quickly. Maybe make the wood look slightly burn and have layers. Have the lighting look more realistic.

1 Like

just a thought but where does the smoke go.
Doesn’t it need a hole in the chimney?

2 Likes

It Might Be A Modern Electrical Fireplace With Fake Flames

4/10

  • Add More Detail (Take Note When Making Single Assets Make Sure You Add So Much Detail)
1 Like

3/10. Not much detail, wood logs are plastic, not realistic whatsoever.

I recommend using different textures or even texture decals to make it look more real.

For the fire use fire particles and add smoke at the top.

If you did the things I recommended, I’d give it an 8/10 or 9/10.

1 Like

By normal standards, it ranks quite low but seeing as you just started out, I think you’ve done a great job. I am sure you’ve put a lot effort in it, I commend you for that.

Keep improving, you’ve a long way to go, so enjoy the journey ^^

1 Like