Place link: Terrain test - Roblox
also if this is in the wrong topic kindly let me know and i will move it.
Best way to format your feedback to make it easier for me to read.
Realistic-ness - (your feedback, rating out of 5)
Detail - (your feedback, rating out of 5)
Style - (how it looks compared to mountains) (your feedback, rating out of 5)
Would you use this - (your feedback, rating out of 5)
Pricing - (how much would it go for, not saying i will sell it but this will give me an idea of the quality
Anything else (what you dont like maybe)
Thanks in advance for feedback!
Edit:it won’t let me move this post to a different topic, so it has to be here sorry
Great work! I have basically zero experience with terrain, so I can’t comment on the quality of your work. From an outsider’s perspective, it looks great! My only real suggestion would be to make it less holey/have fewer indents.
Also, unfortunately, this is the wrong topic. Try Cool Creations, under Help and Feedback. Good luck!
I’d add some trees and rocks along with smoothing the terrain.
ROBLOX has also recently added a grass feature on the grass terrain. It can be turned on by selection terrain in the work-space and enabling Decorations.
You just need to follow the Post Approval process. It can take a few days, to even a week, but if your post isn’t violating the rules, it should get approved.
I’m not a staff member, but I’m saying this for your sake, it’d be sad if you get banned from the DevForum because you put a topic into the wrong place on purpose. Always bad for a talented dev like you to lose access to a good resource.
Very nice for your first try, Though I would recommend you to use the “Grow” tool and add a few details with the Rock Texture. It gives a more Aesthetic feel and rocky nature to the hill. I would also recommend you to add a few details to the shore so that it looks more aesthetic.
This is very good for a first, I like how you’ve made mountains to this and sand to add realistic to this,
My suggestion would maybe use a smooth tool on the mountains so its less blocky and more of a rough terrain, with this fix I would definitely use it,
Another suggestion is maybe adding in a cave and/or tree’s to the terrain.
Right now I would pay 150 - 350 robux for this terrain as it currently is,
If you added these suggestions I would price it at 250 - 500 robux
For a start, it is good. The terrain is kind of spiky and looks weird. You could add some rocks on the sides of hills and maybe smooth it out, a lot.
Over all-terrain: 2
You could add stuff like trees, bushes, and even use the new Roblox grass (Check “Decoration” in “terrain” in workspace).
Terrain Detail: 2
It’s a Really good start tho, keep working with terrain
Realistic - I’ll give this a 4/5 Detail - I’m not entirely sure how I can rate this, the only types of terrain I see are water, sand, and grass. Try out using the new grass feature with Roblox as well, as it is a really good addition to the look of terrain. I’m not rating on trees, etc seeing as this post is about terrain. Style - For this I’ll have to give an honest 3/5. The shape of the mountains looks good, but I feel like it needs a more rocky type of terrain. Possibly Basalt? I do think the look of the area does give me an island type of feel though, and the mountains look pretty impressive from farther away. Would I use it? - I would not use it, mostly because of the fact I don’t do many terrain based games. However, if I am ever to make an exploration or escape-type game, I might do something similar (Think a game such as Isle.).
Other comments: As I said earlier, I feel like there isn’t enough detail showing the mountains are actually, mountains. Try using some different textures on the terrain. Another thing, in the second photo there are a couple of pieces that really just out from the terrain, try smoothing them out a bit so it doesn’t look so, blocky and more natural. Overall, if this is your first big peice of terrain, good job, and keep learning!
so that it looks more aesthetic.
