Feedback on game icon

I’m planning on redeveloping a game i made a while back and the current icon is a bit off in my opinion however im unsure on how it can be improved.

I want something which still reflects towards a younger audience however I want feedback on the current icon to then construct another icon through feedback to ensure its of a good enough standard. Will i hire someone? Probably not as im broke until my limited sells for 5,000 Robux which will be in a while probably and even then i may not spend too much on an icon as well…im a cheapskate.

The Icon


Apologies for it being so small. I had to directly pull it from roblox as that file is on my old computer.

Thank you for the feedback in advance.