Feedback on game icon

I was making a game icon for the first time, when I realized it looked a lot worse than anticipated. I could honestly care less about reassurance, but what I’m really looking for is places to improve and how to specifically improve in those said aspects.

Here’s the icon:

Potential things you might want to talk about:

  • The text on my held sign
  • The brightness of the icon (is it too bright/too dim?)
  • The blandness of the icon
  • The blurriness/pixelated (is it good/too much blurriness?)
1 Like

This game icon looks great! I recommend putting the title of the game in it, unless the title is too long or something catchy. Other than that, it would be good if the text of the sign was somehow bigger so it’s more visible when it’s smaller as an icon. Nice job on this! How long did it take to make? What game will it be used in?

1 Like

This will be used in my history trivia, round-based game.

Thanks for the feedback, too answer your questions.
It took me about two hours to make it, I will definitely try to make the sign bigger in the very near future, and this is would be what it looks like with the addition of text:

Do you think it looks better or worse with text on it?

1 Like

Looks good no blank spaces anymore.

2 Likes

Be careful, anything involving presidents can get you banned. Roblox does not want politics

2 Likes

After looking at it for a bit, and seeing how the icon had a 0.4% CTR, I decided to redo the icon completely.

I wanted to mainly address the visibility issues with the text, and I wanted to make it pop with more eye-catching colors.
This is not the final product, but this is something in the realm of how I want it to look, unless I want to completely revamp it again:

1 Like

it should tell me what the game is about, like having a button the character is pressing for the correct answer or something

1 Like

No idea why you ignored @RocketSlither’s warning, but to confirm, yes this will probably get you banned if uploaded or used in your game.

But the logo itself is very good.

1 Like

I’m still confused on what you guys mean by not having politics. It’s more of a historical question. Do you mean if mods mistake it as political, b/c then that could be a legitimate concern.