Feedback on game logo for thumbnails

Help and Feedback Creations Feedback
#1

Hiya, I’m highly not sure if this is the correct place to actually post + ask but oh well.

I created this logo which will be used for some thumbnails for my upcoming game that I’ve been working on with some friends for a while now, and it’s been a few months since I practiced on making this logo over and over to hopefully make it look better as I can make it.

I’d highly love any feedback on how I can improve this! This actually wasn’t created using Photoshop, but instead I used Photopea which is basically Photoshop but free.

image

10 Likes
Commission Logo Feedback
#2

Looks really nice just could use a background! I rate 8/10

2 Likes
#3

Thanks! Don’t worry, I plan to use that on the thumbnails once the game is near finished for release, so basically it’d have a background!

1 Like
#4

It looks pretty good, honestly! I think you should add like, a little sword icon by the letters or something, idk. Still looks good, though!

1 Like
#5

Planning on doing that, thanks!

#6

With the background, I think it should be like players fighting.
What do I rate it? I rate it about 7/10.
What should you improve/make? A background, maybe like swords stacked against the text.
Overall, it is good. Listen to the improvments here and I think your thumbnail will be close to a 10/10! Good luck on your new game! :smiley:

1 Like
#7

Thanks for the feedback! I’ll make sure to listen to the improvements! :+1:

1 Like
#8

I love this thumbnail. It reminds me of comics and such. Great job!

1 Like
#9

Great logo! My only critique is the lack of anti-aliasing of the edges. It looks a bit jagged although this could just be from the screenshot and not the actual logo itself.

1 Like
#10

Thanks! And yeah, I’m highly sure that it’s just from the screenshot.

1 Like
#11

I suggest have the name stand out, like a sword on the logo to represent sword, and explosions to represent chaos, in the other hand good logo, 8/10!

1 Like
#12

Thanks for the feedback!! :+1:

#13

Hey, I know it has been 17 days, but could you send an image now after all the improvements? I would like to see it after all the improvements.

1 Like
#14

Oh, I hadn’t gotten the chance to improve the logo yet, since I’ve been busy due to personal reasons. However, don’t worry, I’ll 100% show the improvements once I have the time!

#15

I’d say 1-10

7.5- 8.5

great work, Keep going!

#16

Hey there!

The logo looks very clean. I would suggest adding a red stroke around the black.
Also, looking at the graphic I can see a faint line. I’m assuming you were trying to create a gradient. You can fix it up by going into photoshop, or any editing software and using the gradient tool they have! For photoshop I would look under the gradient overlayer section! Other than that adding trow swords coming out the top, would look great!

Hope this helps!

#17

6.5/10 because you gotta add more things to it like a background, a themed texture and other stuff this looks like you did a text edit and remove edit the white background
(Sorry if I’m being rude it’s just for a change)
You can do better than this! But good job

#18

They said they would add a backround.