Feedback on game

Give me some feedback on it!

6 Likes

Nice map, there should definitely be a goal for the player to reach though. Some small things that you could maybe change are how the cartoon outlines for the mushrooms and trees have a bottom, they could be cemented into in the ground. Maybe also make the checkpoints invisible but cool game!

2 Likes

Thanks for your feedback! charlimit

2 Likes

Hi I_ButteryMe,

The core mechanic is interesting and the map is nice, although the experience still lacks the basic elements that define a game (mechanics, rules, goal).

The trickiest problem I see is in the idea, because the end user, by linking the earning of points with writing in chat, will disrupt the function of the chat (and thus the idea of the game itself): spamming random words, perhaps aided by an automation tool.

In this sense, the game will lose its uniqueness and indeed acquire complication (which is different from complexity), because at that point there are games in which one only has to exist or click the mouse on the screen to achieve the same result.

So the idea is interesting, I suggest you think of acceptable rules to keep the experience unique and meaningful (e.g. trivially answering logic questions, increase in size).

Also in anticipation of an MVP I suggest you create a simple GUI chat to check and validate the results, as well as to optimise the memory consumed by the messages (I donโ€™t know if they are saved in the server and for how long by the standard roblox chat)

2 Likes