Feedback on Melee System

[Miserable_Haven]

I made a melee weapon system. It works as intended, and I’m looking for ways to improve the system.

Meele Test

There is only 2 tools right now. There are NPCs to fight on the baseplate. Keep in mind, I am not a good animator, so these animations may be bad.

Press E to punch and kick

Tools

plank
katana

Animations

plank
katana in game

Poll:

• 5/5, Perfect.
• 4.5/5 It is very good!
• 4/5, Great, could be a bit better.
• 3.5/5, It is good, needs some improvement, has potential.
• 3/5, Not that good, needs improvement.
• 2/5, Really bad. Improve a lot.
• 1/5, This is so trash, I almost puked while playing the game. Fix the whole game.

Reply what option you choose and why if you want.

[bluebxrrybot (blueberry)]

The animations seem pretty linear, try moving more limbs (including the head!), and coming back to the idle state more gradually instead of quickly.

[zirdic]

Im gonna be honest the animations arent really good make it so that the body movement is in sync with the melee movement

Ill give you an example

look at how the body is moving with the melee as the katana strikes, it makes the animation feel more heavy, realistic and it makes it appear like its having more impact

[30% OFF] Advanced Realistic Melee Combat System - Roblox Studio [UPDATED]

[Freddd7878 (Fred)]

Maybe lower the sound of the katana a little…

[Miserable_Haven]

@bluebxrrybot

The animations seem pretty linear, try moving more limbs (including the head!), and coming back to the idle state more gradually instead of quickly.

@zirdic

Im gonna be honest the animations arent really good make it so that the body movement is in sync with the melee movement

Ill give you an example

look at how the body is moving with the melee as the katana strikes, it makes the animation feel more heavy, realistic and it makes it appear like its having more impact

I’m gonna try to recreate some animations and make them better. Also how would i achieve an impact effect? (Animation-wise, I know how to do the screen efect.)

@Freddd7878

Maybe lower the sound of the katana a little…

I think I’ll lower the sound of most tools since it can be a bit too loud

[zirdic]

Idk how you can make it but my suggestion would be to make it where the katana acutally has an impact where it hits the player, instead of it being how it is now where its just so boring and doesn’t feel like it has any impact when hitting a player

Idk how else to explain it

[Freddd7878 (Fred)]

Like adding screen shaking when you hit a player maybe?

[Miserable_Haven]

@zirdic

and it makes it appear like its having more impact

@bluebxrrybot

The animations seem pretty linear, try moving more limbs

I have added an effect on hit, and edited some of katanas animations. I might remove the plank and replace it with a different tool.