Hello, I have this game that I started a couple months ago and I would really appreciate some feedback. Anything you think I should add or change. Thanks.
Edit: I have updated the game a bit since I posted this I would appreciate some more feedback.
Here is the link
Honestly, its a bit…
eh
The map design is repetitive, the building has no real memorable charm to it. The animations feel a bit clunky, and the game idea is simply just ripped from Weightlifting simulator, or any of the other simulators that are out there.
All in all, make the map design a bit more original, as well as spice up your game itself. here, it just seems like another casual simulator. The winter theme doesn’t really work, considering you just put a quick particle effect.
You might also want to check out why there are 4 different punches that do the exact same thing
i wasnt hearing any music, maybe add some
It’s a decent start so far. I like the variance you’ve added in the trees with them being different colours. There are several issues I’ve identified which I’ll list below.
Since my character is so small and fast, it’s incredibly difficult to grab the money as I have to jump and run, causing me to miss most of the time. Upon grabbing the money, there’s no kind of feedback to let me know I’ve grabbed it, such as sound or a visual indicator.
The UI here doesn’t change colour or look any different when I hover over it or click it, nor does it have any sound when clicking.
In addition to these points, the map boundaries could do with some improvement; I was able to see behind the cliffs, particularly in the corners of the map. A good way to improve this would be to add a limit on the max camera distance so I can’t zoom out as far.
Upon joining the server, the snow particles also take time to hit the ground. This is only a minor fault, but I’m presuming this wasn’t intentional.
Overall, I think adding sound effects, music and ambience would drastically improve your game. Off the top of my head, you could include audio when:
Despite these issues, it is a good start. I’d be happy to test it again should you need me to in future.
Thanks for the feedback. Btw the punches do different damage.
It’s not too bad… Although, the map is relatively bland. There’s nothing interesting or charming that’ll catch the player’s attention, and make them want to walk around and explore the area…
As another user mentioned, the game could use some music. Silence is nice and all, but not in a game like this, where your sole purpose is just clicking and punching other players.
The animations are a bit clunky, and persistent and could use some touch-ups.
I also don’t see the point in having 4 different punch types. I understand they do different damage, but in a game like this, your damage should increase as you progress.
Other than that, the game is pretty decent. It’s not really my type of game, but I’m sure it appeals to other players. Good luck with the future of your game, and I hope to see you succeed.
The problem with having your damage increase as you progress is that I’m not really sure how to do that. Any suggestions?
Nope it was only glitch from the boss walking to me.
The game is really good basics you will get good in desings in future.
Keep practicing!
The game concept is good, nothing bad about it. But about the map. It’s repetitive. Also, leaderboard doesn’t work on other players.
I’ve had a couple of suggestions on this one.
Change the punch animations. They are all nearly the same.
The snow falls on the ground and the ground is still green.
The noob boss is hovering.
The cash is going up and down but not touching the ground.
Some houses look exactly the same.
The extra anims are gonna get removed, I’ll add snow on the ground, I fixed the boss but haven’t updated, the cash is suppose to be hovering, and I’ll try to give the houses more variety. All in all thanks for the help
Imma try to fix that.
It’s probably gonna be redone too! :D.
Hm how could you fix that?
Good idea!
I’ve made some changes and would really appreciate some new feedback.
I suggest you make a small tutorial and add more objetives.
