Feedback on my game's icon and thumbnail

Hello, I am working on a project and i noticed that it was missing an icon and thumbnail, so i decided to make some. The thumbnail Is down here and the icon is too. I would appreciate it if you left a comment telling me how they looked and what I should improve.

Unfortunately i have to put watermarks in case someone decides to take them. If you want to see the full and unwatermarked icons please consider checking out my game down below.

Please note that all the feedback or ratings that you give will help make the icons and game better.


If you want to see the full and unwatermarked icons please consider checking out and play my game: samcampone's gunfight arena - Roblox

Looks fine. A little basic, but not bad

1 Like

Finally! Someone who properly watermarks their images. They seem great, like some of those games with a random title but a memorable logo.

1 Like

It’s too plain… just an image with no background.

1 Like

First impressions, not so good. The edges look rough and pixelated and it’s just way too plain. If you wanted to get someone to click on your thing, I don’t think you’ll find much luck with these icons. Depending on the type of game, you could add a red sunburst in the background which could make it more appealing. Other then that it’s not bad. Hope this helps.

1 Like

There is a 512x512 maximum I think

1 Like

Thanks to everyone who gave/will give feedback. I really appreciate it.

This icon and thumbnail looks great! They’re fairly basic though. You should add something to the background, or make it a gradient color to look better. Nice job on these! How long did they take to make?

1 Like

Thank you! I will consider your feedback. They took me about 30 minutes for both.