Hello. I am Zombie2358, an experienced roblox developer that started working with Roblox Studio back in 2018.
I have made an fan remake of an old hitman game in roblox. I have noticed that the rating is 72% currently. But i have expected at least 80%. I am not sure why the rating is getting lower everytime i advertise the game.
I need people to test and send feedback here and tell me about any suggestions you have. Thank you.
Game link:
Can’t play right now, but games with to realistic thumbnails often lose credibility, as they seem cheap, and got a thumbnail from a quick google search! 
Ok but the thumbnails were designed by an gfx artist i hired. Except the first thumbnail, which is from the original game.
Mhmm! I’m not saying it’s from google, just that it looks like that, and I know personally, when I see a game, that has a realistic human face on it, it often seems low quality, sorry for the pretty bad advice by the way! I can’t play right now so sadly, can’t look more in depth then the thumbnail and other superficial layers!
Ok i will make sure to change the thumbnails soon. Thanks for your feedback.
Improve the build. Add more details and fix lighting. Maybe try adding barrels or dead bodies or carts around the area to add more detail, maybe even flickering lights.
The UI could also be improved and moved somewhere better. Green and black and the font when you’re playing isn’t exactly appealing.
A change in the thumbnail would be good, too. Thumbnails capture the players attention and dictates if they want to play or not. Make a GFX with the text logo of it.
Maybe add a tutorial? It could be a little confusing for some people. Maybe add music too.
Overall the gameplay is good. Goodluck with the game!
Thanks for your feedback. Therefore, the lighting is supposed to be like that in Training. Other missions have sunny weather and good lighting. Music is also there except Training. Thumbnails and Gui will get changed. And the level of detail will also get improved.
Very honest review by me. Keep in mind I haven’t FULLY played old hitman games. I have only fully played hitman on PS4 so I can’t tell if anything in the game is supposed to be similar to old hitman games.
==
Game page
I like the image where Agent 47 is reading a newspaper. The other two, I don’t like them. There is a non-blocky Agent 47, and then there is a GFX that has VERY SHINY characters. The description could use some work. You should use the game description as one of the ways to attract players more to the game. You should say what the game is all about.
UI (User Interface) and UX (User Experience)
It’s… let’s say it’s not so good. You used low quality images. The buttons don’t look appealing and there’s not much feedback. The minimap was very sensitive for some reason.
Gameplay
TL;DR: It’s really confusing and definitely needs a lot of work.
I don’t like how the character is blocking the way of the mouse. I had to use camera-toggle. If you can do only camera-toggle, that would be nice.
I really had no idea where to go (I only played tutorial and the first mission). I’m not sure if there were anything like an indicator to tell me where to go or it just didn’t load in. If there’s nothing like that, then I suggest you add one so players can see where they’re supposed to go. It’s very confusing when the objectives only say ‘Find the sniper building’ when almost every building looks similar. Could’ve used more information about where the sniper building is. I eventually found it though.
The weapons do work but they look decent.
One thing I also noticed about the game is the camera transitions, they’re confusing and also looks awkward.
Visuals
Lighting? Not so bad. Building? Definitely needs a lot of work.
Others
You should consider lag. I had a high ping and when I was at an elevator, I went through it and had to rejoin just to ride the elevator again lol.
Rating: 5.5/10. Still nice.
==
Your game has a potential and I believe it can be much, much better. I mean I’m not expecting a lot from your game, it’s just that it needs more work. It really is like a Hitman game but you could have pulled it off better. I hope you don’t take this personally and take it as an opportunity to make the game better. When I say that your game has a potential, I really do mean it has a potential.
Thank you for your feedback. I will look forward at fixing most of the things you told me.
I have played the new hitman games too and all i can say that the older hitman games were more simple and similar to this one.
You should add suspense music in the training.
I assume the reason you’re getting dislikes is that your game isn’t being positively perceived by the people who chose to play it.
You’re remaking an older game, while the audience on the platform is mostly younger children, who don’t know what Hitman is.
Some feedback about your Game:
I understand you’re making a remake, so I’m not sure how far from that original path you’re wanting to go, but I think guiding people will help, especially people who are completely unfamiliar with your specific game.
I have managed to improve most of the things you guys told me. But I need someone to test it again.
Just tested out the tutorial and all is very good until i got to the elevator part. i fell down through the moving elevator, so can you try fix that? also there should be a third perspective with the camera on the right shoulder of the player.
Thank you.
The elevator is using TweenService. The only thing i can do is make the elevator slower. But you fell through it if your game is laggy or if you have high ping.
Third perspective might get added.
Make the elevator tween locally so it’s smooth for players.
Ok that might work. Thanks for your answer.
I like the game, but it needs a TON of rework. Graphical rework, Gameplay rework, AI Rework etc.
The images in the game were pixelated like they were taken of google. The game is good for a Pre-Alpha state.