I would like if you give me feedback on these GFX and which one do you think is the best. I made these icons for my upcoming clothing group “Into My Mind”
4 Likes
Either the second or the third as they add a noise grain filter which replicates a realistic camera. Personally, I would pick the second one but add the hue/contrast element from the third but by just a bit. As for feedback, center the bottom text, add a texture onto the sun/moon behind yourself, or blend in textures such as dirt or scratches onto the clothing. Another thing to consider is incorporating smoke effect layers or using cloud brushes with an opacity of around five to ten around the character.
i really like it
nice vibe
Everything blends in perfectly
1 Like
The We Dragons, We Different, doesn’t sound really good grammar wise.
The pose is great! As well as the effects added to them! I think you did a good job on this!
I agree that it doesn’t sound grammar wise.
Thank you, I didn’t put a lot of time on the pose, glad you like it.
1 Like
Thank you, I will do all the stuff you mentioned in one of my upcoming work.
All three of your images are basically the exact same design. If your goal is to do different variations, they should be noticably different. For professional design work, we usually do 3 - 6 different designs and then let the client choose.
Also, I wonder where you got the idea from the design. Did you just pull this out of your head? Professional designers actually look at lots of different designs, and try to find something to model their design on. Some might even call it copying. But the idea is to do research to get ideas on look and feel, then adapt it to your own design problem.
Different would mean: different layouts, styles, imagery, colors, type treatments (fonts), etc.
The final part is testing. Just as we test code, we test designs, by showing it to targeted users. The idea would be to present your test group, (can be as few as 3- 5 people), tell them "please rate the following designs as to which best represents our clothing design group.
Look up “user centered design”, for example:
What is User Centered Design? | IxDF.
1 Like
PS keep in mind the size your are designing for. If this is an icon, it has to “read” really well at a small size. One thing that annoys me is that almost all game icons on Roblox include text. This is really not necessary, because the name of the game or group is listed immediately below the icon. Notice how icons are designed for mobile apps, especially iPhone apps, which, of course, need to display even smaller than Roblox game apps, but its the same idea.
I like the first pfp that’s cooler 
But yeah, Thank you for reading this. have a nice day! 