I was trying a new style for my roblox group icon. I was wondering which one is better
Old (current)
or
I am always looking for feedback on how I could improve!
2 Likes
I like the old one’s design more, though the font and text overall feels a little off. I think that the potentially new one feels a little flat with little contrast. IMO, a logo, especially something like a group logo, should be relatively simple with clear contrast between different elements, and I think the old logo accomplishes that better. However the “StoreS” text on the old logo should probably use a font with a heavier weight, and one that pops. The spacing between the first and last S is also inconsistent, and you should bring the first one closer to the “tore” while spacing out the last one more.
Thanks! I’m working on a re-design now 
I think the text is better, but you should probably pick a more stylized font. I also think you should also add the background of the original logo back, because I think that made the logo pop more.
You should make the store clipart and text black, because the green doesn’t really pop. You also have some whitespace in the background that you should probably fill in
I think its a lot better! I would just recommend lowering the saturation of the background circles though, since the high saturation is kinda hard to look at (at least for me). I also liked how the old icon had only 4-5 circles, as the new icon right now feel a little cluttered, though if that is what you are going for, then that’s fine. Here is an example of how I would change it (this is just a quick adjustment on your current icon)
Corners were supposed to be transparent, but I just forgot to export as a png
2 Likes
keep the old one. the new one is janky.
The old (current) logo looks much better. Designs are best for logos, not real things. Nice job on it!