Feedback on this Forest

Help and Feedback Creations Feedback
#1

Hey everyone! I was working on this forest and would like some feedback! Would you play a game like this?

The trees and spawn area are from a asset pack from Synty Nature Pack

For anyone who wants to play the game.

RobloxScreenShot20210806_162148987
RobloxScreenShot20210806_162148987913Ă—599 213 KB

7 Likes
#2

Looks sooo realistic! Awesome.

#3

Thanks! Would you play a game like this? A walk in the forest?

1 Like
#4
Just a poll! Would you play this?
  • Yes
  • No

0 voters

#5

Yeah I would be it really shouldn’t be boring…

#6

Hello, A few This I would like to point out.
#1 You used the same tree model over and over
#2 The trees are in straight rows which looks un natraul
#3 Lack of variation. You need something that looks natural and believable.
#4 Vary the height and size of the trees. This is a very small thing but does wonder.
Can’t wait to see what you do with this, Best regards ~Stone

11 Likes
#7

You are right! I will fix all of that.

1 Like
#8

Alright I have fixed some trees used different tree models !

RobloxScreenShot20210806_165330135
RobloxScreenShot20210806_165330135913Ă—599 430 KB

3 Likes
#9

Thanks for feedback!!! Thanks.

#10

Hmm, You cant make it like 40% that tree 40% another and 20% of another? That would look Excelent, Also Adding little hills and bumps in the terrain will help alot with this visual appeal along with a skybox and atmosphere.

3 Likes
#11

Looks great but the trees look very copy & pasted. In the latest screenshot there’re different tree models but they are all at the same height. Luckily there’s a plugin that can randomly rotate and resize models. Put in a few different trees and then use the plugin and it will look much better!

Brushtool

1 Like
#12

The brush tool was used, that’s why the trees look copy and pasted.

#13

Well there are many trees there was more than one model of trees added.

#14

Just one thing the trees here are to straight and not random enough Yes1
In real life the trees are a little straight but there still a little random.

2 Likes
#15

Yep I noticed that and it was changed.

1 Like
#16

You should use a more realistic tree because of the terrain. The tree you are using is low poly, which does not match the terrain. I would recommend using trees out of this pack: Forest Pack - Roblox

I think I would play this game.

#17

Alright the trees might change in a future update!

#18

Im not really a fan but ways to make it look a lot better:

  1. Change tree heights
  2. Use different trees
  3. Make trees less lined up (make it more random)
  4. Make terrain less flat
    :moyai:
#19

Most trees are different heights
There is more than 1 model of trees
The terrain is all flat.

#20

My bad i meant less flat :moyai: