Feedback on thumbnails and icon for my game

I’m planning to advertise my game so I need to know if my thumbnails are good enough for it.
The game is called Capture The Castle, where two teams try to capture eachothers castle and they fight with medieval weapons.

Logo:
Logo3

Thumbnail 1:

Thumbnail 2:


Thumbnail 3:

How would you rate these thumbnails?

  • 1⭐
  • 2⭐
  • 3⭐
  • 4⭐
  • 5⭐

0 voters

If you saw these thumbnails, would you click on them? (assuming you are interested in these kind of games)

  • Yes, definitely
  • Probably
  • Maybe
  • Probably not
  • Definitely not

0 voters

Which thumbnail is the best?

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3

0 voters

If you have any improvement ideas, please tell me.

1 Like

Try supporting your thumbnails with blender renders because plain roblox screenshots barely look good and some shadow built in blender makes it x2 better while being the same environment

1 Like

This icon and the thumbnails look great! Good job on them! How long did it take for you to make these? What’s the game they’ll be used in? I recommend making more thumbnails if you can and want to, the more the better!

1 Like

the thumbnails are good but im not too sure about the logo

1 Like

Thanks for the advice, I’ll try that.

Thanks, I’ll probably make more thumbnails in the future for practice. Each one took me like 3+ hours I think.
The game they will be used in is this: Capture the Castle [Beta] - Roblox

you definitely need to work on the lighting, without shadows it makes your game look realllllly bland. also, shrink your mini logo on the thumnails quite a bit and work on positioning it better.

i belive once you’ve done that it’ll all look better :slightly_smiling_face:

1 Like

It could use some shadows and better rendering (like blender) and unrelated to thumbnails and icon, but in the game tutorial, when breaking the second gate he durability bar wasn’t going down, I had to move away from it and return and then it would show the correct durability but with full health bar

1 Like

Thanks for the tips, I’m going to improve the shadows and shrink the logo.

Thanks for the feedback and the bug report. Is the gate bug in the tutorial or in the main game?

It is in the game tutorial, idk about the main game because i had little time to check out the entire game.

1 Like