Firing problems with my FPS system (fires from under the map)

Quick overview, but please view the code sample and the screenshots:
It’s quite weird, but sometimes the gun shoots from below the map. I’m not sure if it’s the code or the attachment.

  1. What do you want to achieve?
    I need help fixing my FPS system that is based off of Writing an FPS framework (2020) (Check it out if you haven’t, it is a great tutorial!), parts 1 and 2. Everything is working great except for the actual firing.
  2. What is the issue? Include screenshots / videos if possible!
    The gun sometimes fires from below the map. I have no clue why exactly, I have not yet detected a pattern. Things to note: The receiver itself is facing backwards, but the attachment is facing forward. To test, I added small blocks to trace the bullet and large blocks for the point where it fires from (Large purple is the position, and large black is the position and orientation).

Screenshots:
Receiver information and position (Note that the way the mesh is imported it is backward, I will fix it soon, but it shouldn’t be a problem):
image
Attachment information (Should be facing backward in relation to the its parent the receiver):
image
Finally, the main photo of the shots under the map:


The orientation seems to be fine for some reason.

The code for firing (The handler works fine, but I can add the code if you want. Let me know.)
You don’t have to read it all right away if you don’t want, the important lines are below. Its included in case anyone notices problems with it:

function handler:fire(tofire)
	--Requirements for firing here, there are a lot so I cut them out.
	
	-- this makes the loop stop running when set to false
	self.firing = tofire
	if not tofire then return end
	
	-- while lmb held down do
	local function fire(semi)
		if self.ammo[self.wepName] <= 0 then return end
		
		-- It's better to replicate the change to other clients and play it there with the same code as here instead of using SoundService.RespectFilteringEnabled = false
		local sound = self.viewmodel.receiver.pewpew:Clone()
		sound.Parent = self.viewmodel.receiver
		sound:Play()
		
		game:GetService("Debris"):AddItem(sound,5)
		self.loadedAnimations.fire:Play()
		self.ammo[self.wepName] = self.ammo[self.wepName] - 1
		--local origin = self.viewmodel.receiver.barrel.WorldPosition
		--local direction = self.viewmodel.receiver.barrel.WorldCFrame
		-- addition of deltatime here is a poor attempt at fixing the recoil being framerate based
		-- this doesn't happen in my own game, dunno why
		local min = self.settings.firing.recoil.min
		local max = self.settings.firing.recoil.max
		local random = Random.new(tick())
		local amount = Vector3.new(random:NextNumber(min.x, max.x),random:NextNumber(min.y, max.y), random:NextNumber(min.z, max.z))
		if not semi then
			self.springs.fire:shove(amount * self.deltaTime * 60)
			spawn(function()
				wait(self.settings.firing.recoil.tim)
				self.springs.fire:shove(amount * Vector3.new(-1,-1,-1) * self.deltaTime * 60)
			end)
		end
		-- Muzzle flash. This is why we left it invisible and enabled.
		coroutine.wrap(function()		
			
			-- could be optimized a lot
			-- flash flashes inside the barrel, and smoke smokes for a short time
			
			for i,v in pairs(self.viewmodel.receiver.barrel:GetChildren()) do
				if v.Name == "flash" then
					v.Transparency = NumberSequence.new(v.transparency.Value)
				elseif v.Name == "smoke" then
					v.Enabled = true
				end
			end	
			
			wait()
			
			for i,v in pairs(self.viewmodel.receiver.barrel:GetChildren()) do
				if v.Name == "flash" then
					v.Transparency = NumberSequence.new(1)
				elseif v.Name == "smoke" then
					v.Enabled = false
				end
			end		
			
		end)()		
		
		-- origin, direction
		-- barrel because realism, camera.CFrame because uh accuracy and arcadeying 
		-- make sure the barrel is facing where the gun fires
		-- aaand make sure the gun is actually facing towards the cursor properly, players don't like offsets
		
		local origin = self.viewmodel.receiver.barrel.WorldPosition
		local part = Instance.new("Part")
		part.Size = Vector3.new(4,4,4)
		part.Anchored = true
		part.Position = origin
		part.Name = "ORIGIN"
		part.Parent = workspace.fastCast
		part.BrickColor = BrickColor.new("Black")
		local direction = self.viewmodel.receiver.barrel.WorldCFrame
		local part = Instance.new("Part")
		part.Size = Vector3.new(4,4,4)
		part.Anchored = true
		part.CFrame = direction
		part.Name = "Direction"
		part.Parent = workspace.fastCast
		part.BrickColor = BrickColor.new("Royal purple")
		-- inconsistent :(
		fastcastHandler:fire(origin, direction, self.settings)
		print("FIRE CHECK 2")
		if type(self.settings.firing.automatic) ~= "number" then
			wait(60/self.settings.firing.rpm)
		end
	end
	if self.settings.firing.automatic and type(self.settings.firing.automatic) ~= "number" then
		repeat
			self.canFire = false
			fire()
			self.canFire = true
		until self.ammo[self.wepName] <= 0 or not self.firing
	elseif type(self.settings.firing.automatic) == "number" then
		local amount = 1
		repeat
			self.canFire = false
			if amount == self.settings.firing.automatic then
				fire()
			else
				fire(true)
			end
			self.canFire = true
			amount += 1
			wait(0.1)
		until self.ammo[self.wepName] <= 0 or amount > self.settings.firing.automatic
		self.canFire = false
		wait(60/self.settings.firing.rpm)
		self.canFire = true
	else
		self.canFire = false
		fire()
		print("FIRECHECK1")
		self.canFire = true
	end
	
	if self.ammo[self.wepName] <= 0 then
		self.firing = false
	end
	
end

Specific lines:

local origin = self.viewmodel.receiver.barrel.WorldPosition
local direction = self.viewmodel.receiver.barrel.WorldCFrame
fastcastHandler:fire(origin, direction, self.settings)
  1. What solutions have you tried so far?
    I flipped the attachment around, as I noticed it was facing the wrong way. I’ve mainly messed around with the attachment, but I have not noticed an issue with the code.

If any part of the system does not make sense, feel free to ask me a question or refer to the tutorial linked above.

Thanks for reading!

1 Like

It might be a bit old but here is the issue I believe due to similarities in the problem. Sorry for bumping the thread but no one answered it :stuck_out_tongue: .

1 Like

No problem on the bumping! I found that thread a month ago, and that fixed my issue. A decent (well, it’s really not that good, but you at least shoot at the same height) temporary solution for those that are interested (which is what I used until I found it) is to use the player’s gun model (not the viewmodel) to fire from. I’ll go ahead and mark your post as the solution.

Thanks for the reply! I had completely forgotten about this topic…

2 Likes