First Logo on Photopea (Feedback?)

Help and Feedback Creations Feedback
,
#1

So, I recently just decided to make a new logo and I would like some feedback. What could be better? Rate it out of 10, and would you commission me? Let me know your thoughts on my first logo made on PhotoPea !

New Project
New Project512×512 447 KB

#2

I like it, 8.4/10. Though I think it’s a bit excessive and doesn’t really appeal to me.

1 Like
#3

why did you rate it a 8.4 if you think its excessive and unappealing to you

#4

I like it! Photopea is a great website for all things roblox related (I honestly like it more than photoshop)! I personally am not a big fan of the bottom text being transparent, but I think it’s fine! Probably an 8/10. I probably would commission you if I didn’t already know how to use photopea!

#5

the deduction of 1.6 from 10 was because it was excessive and unappealing to him

#6

I’d give it a 5 of 10.

I Like:

  • The color scheme (I like the purple)
  • The urban look

My problems:

  • Doesn’t stand out to me. It would look like a colorful blob among other group thumbnails.
    image
    image1920×1045 121 KB
  • Adding to my previous point, the text doesn’t stand out on the background, as both are purple and white. I’d suggest making the text contrast from the purple with either cyan or yellow.
  • It’s chaotic. I get that’s the idea, but it’s not good as an icon. If you look at some of the groups my friends are in, they all have either big text or a logo.

Overall, it’s good for your first logo. I like the graphic, but for me it just doesn’t work as an icon.

Also should note, I’m not a professional graphic designer, these are just my ideas and observations.

1 Like
#7

Idk maybe 7.9/10
For me, the first time I saw this, my impression actually looked like a discord group icon, not a roblox game icon feeling.

1 Like
#8

I’m saying it wouldn’t appeal to me if it was the main logo as something, and it seems like too much.

#9

This logo looks good! I rate it 8/10. Nice job on it! I recommend making the white bottom text more visible. Otherwise, it’s cool! How long did it take for you to make?

#10

It was for a watermark, but I typically would make it more visible and pop out if it was apart of the logo. Ehh, after a short tutorial on youtube it took like 10 minutes probably! Thanks!!

#11
  1. i would recommend simplifying the background as it creates a lot of visual noise and clutter
  2. you should probably make the “killie” part of the more visible as it fades into the background.

other than those points above, it gets the job done perfectly fine. 6.5/10

#12

Ooooohhhhhh, that makes me like it way more! In that case, I do think the text looks a little small, but I think its good!

1 Like