Please provide some feedback on the assets for my mining game! Note that these are all for nature. Only the rocks are for mining and gameplay.
Thanks in advance!
(Still open for feedback!)
7 Likes
your ores looks good!
i think you should change the Ores rock color more “dark” so player can distinguish between rock & ore
1 Like
Thanks for the feedback!
I’m actually planning for rocks to be minable too. But there will be more rocks than ore, in order to also fill in empty spaces in scenery
(i guess this is a random leak to what gameplay will be like lol)
1 Like
The ores look a little weird to me, because all the minerals sprout at the top. Maybe spread em out more, with more randomness in the gem sizes. imo the gems should be bigger in some places and smaller in other.
The rock models are on point tho 
1 Like
I made the ores like that because I want the users to be able to count how many crystals there is on each rock. There’s actually a designated pattern.
But i get what you mean! normal crystals are supposed to pop out from the center, with different sizes.
Mine is more like… gemstones, let’s say 
1 Like
These look very good, but rocks could have more variation. Maybe do some face editing to give them more personality.
1 Like
thanks for the feedback. I was gonna do more styles, but I think this should be fine. There’s a total of 84 ore styles lol.
Also, I’m gonna be randomly generating the ore’s rotation and size via scripting.
Good! Tbh, the rocks do look a little strange, – however, I know you’re trying to go with a low poly look – just because they seem so round (the ones with gems look strange like that, the others don’t). But it looks good, a lot better than anything I could do!
Thanks for your feedback. The picture perhaps wasn’t displaying it close enough due to crystals blocking the rock itself. Here. Take a look at the close up!
1 Like
They certainly look a lot better up close, though it also may be that I am not used to seeing big chunks of mineral rock everywhere lol
lol yep
my game has variety 
1 Like
I need more feedback before i move on! Please, give some feedback! It would be greatly appreciated!
Thanks!
I need replies. Please reply if possible!
I like the ico sphere trees. Though the pine trees look a bit “linear”. Maybe make some curves (not having all straight edged on the triangles) in them to make more diversity. The ores are pretty cool thought I’m kind of confused why are there so many different sizes if someone could just resize them manually to fit their needs.
Overall this low poly pack looks good thought the rocks kind of break the whole low poly theme with the smoothing.
