Improve Search functionality on DevForum

Forum Help Forum Features
#1

image
image828×1792 269 KB

https://devforum.roblox.com/t/is-g-shared-really-that-bad/754740/

I’m really confused as to why this didn’t show up as the first result but instead completely irrelevant Topics?

Google returns much more accurate results

image
image828×1792 303 KB

I don’t get it, why is the search showing Topics from Announcements first when they are completely unrelated

6 Likes
#2

This is likely because the built-in Discourse search is somewhat naive and ignores certain characters.

We’re aware of this issue and it’s on the near-term roadmap to improve.

11 Likes
#3

I’ve gotten this too. Whenever I search anything up the top announcements come up, then my query.

1 Like
#4

It’s annoying that unrelated announcements show up first then you have to scroll down. Workaround is to “search” for only this category in topic

1 Like
#5

image
image698×876 110 KB

I don’t think I can agree with your statement

#6

Can you elaborate?

1 Like
#10

the search with the keyword “Exploit” but it returned irrelevant results if you look at the screenshot you’ll see many topics from Announcement

1 Like
#11

Right, so just confirming, it’s the same issue I acknowledged here? Or is there anything you disagree with in this post?

1 Like
#13

I believe the issue here is that the search feature doesn’t distinguish between whether the keyword appears in the topic or in a reply. I think that adding a toggle to only show topics where the keyword is in the topic itself would help resolve this.

#14

Already exists, write in:first in your search query or select it from the dropdown:

image
image479×758 54 KB

#15

Oh, ok. Thanks for pointing this out, it actually resolves a lot of the issues with search.

#16

Actually, its because Discourse’s search functionality isn’t based on the title, but on a topic or replies content.

For example, when you search up “exploit”…

image
image427×541 72.3 KB

You see the words that are bolded? That’s the word you searched for, which isn’t in the post’s title, but in a topic’s content or a reply’s content.

TL;DR

The search function is working the way its supposed to.

Its just that certain replies to topics can be completely unrelated to the original post, thus causing unrelated results.

#17

Hence the feature request to “improve search functionality on DevForum”. Your reply seems to go into a circle and end up at the premise of this thread.

The point is when you search “_G” Discourse shows you all posts that contain the letter “g” in some shape or form. There are other situations where Discourse native search breaks down as well.

1 Like