Major issues
Issue 1
Like/Dislike Placement
Positive is always to the right, negative is always to the left.
e.g. Youtube
e.g. Netflix
e.g. Roblox on browser
e.g. Roblox on Xbox
Mobile should similarly be positive to the right, negative to the left, to retain both continuity and as to not confuse users.
Current ratings:
Issue 2
Color
Positive is green, negative is red. Or, simply don’t use color at all, e.g. the examples provided above.
Current ratings:
This is really confusing.
Issue 3
Always use thumbs
Or arrows if you prefer, e.g. Reddit. But not triangles, it is much harder to see which is like or dislike at first glance especially with the swapped positions brought up in issue 1.
Minor Issues
Issue 4
Pluralization of Vote
It would be nice, but is not strictly necessary to have exactly one vote be “Vote” instead of “Votes.”
Current ratings:
