I've only gained 8 members for a 1k ad, is there something wrong with the way my ad is or

I have recently gotten a gfx for ads and started to do ad but sadly I feel like its not worth how much I’m gaining from it.

First, this is what my ad looks like;

Now, I decided to launch 1k of ads before doing 20k (or 10k one time than the rest the other) and I’ve only gained 8 members. On the second run, halfway I’ve only gotten 3 members. I’ve gotten OVER 50000 impressions and now I feel like I shouldn’t do the 20k as it will only get me about 100 members. What do you guys think, do you have any recommendations on what to do? I also have a decently good logo and a good description.

1 Like

It looks like most other ads, to be completely honest. There’s no way you’re getting anywhere by betting just 1k Robux.

1 Like

Because NO one likes restaurant roleplay games except 13 year old girls, femboys, and child predators.

Quite the opposite in fact, and just because you hold this opinion doesn’t mean everyone has the same opinion.

You gained 8 members because you only spent 1k in ads. Bare in mind people spend thousands on ads, 8 members is expected from the amount you spent.

Take a look at this post for example: Feedback on Suno!(Roblox Uno Game) - #4 by X_Z

This user has spent 240k on ads, his return so far, is this…


1k robux is not a lot on ads.

Side note: ads are risky and people barely click on ads anyway… consider sponsoring…? I’ve had a decent amount of luck on ads and sponsoring.

heres some examples…

3 Likes

What’s that game.

Maybe showcase video?

:joy:

I love everything on this guy
The information might be incorrect, but it’s convincing.

Of course! Who the heck is going to do a part-time cashier job for absolutely no payment?

Cafe genre is a overused monopoly.
Time to move on.

5 Likes

As I said, I was just testing this out and am hoping to do about 20k for my next round. At my rate how many members then should I probably get? Although I have a game, the main reason for the ad is to recall users to join the group as well as apply for a position. It could be an in-game one or a higher one in
communications. 7 of the people who clicked joined the communications. Thank you for your help!

1 Like

At least someone isn’t blinded by the fact cafe games eventually always fail.

2 Likes

Ah yes! As you see, the issue is, the majority doesn’t like cafe games, but those who does like them are quite serious about them.

Your best shot is to deliver your ad precisely to them, either on other social medias or try sponsorships.

Do not waste the money before you have a clear strategy!

Good luck but starting a successful cafe game in 2022 is improbable, but not impossible.

Every genre of games eventually fails, but here’s reasons why cafe games are a bit worse.

  1. There’s already too much cafe games, so a lot of people will find them unoriginal and generic, therefore dislike.

  2. There’s people with their favorite cafes, and therefore they attack other cafe games.

  3. Cafe games are too strict and they attract the troller/memer community hate.

  4. Cafe game servers are usually quite empty as there’s not enough gameplay, so “customers” won’t have a good experience.

1 Like

u need to bribe people, like join group for free admin or like ur game cash, because what is the point of joining a cafe group if u just want to be a customer? none.

1 Like

If you want to get group members fast, I would recommend advertising your group in other group walls. While its annoying to most people, it works. It got my group to over 1.5k+ member in a matter of weeks.

Yeah no.
Offering free ranks as the owner isn’t bribing, and it’s also already an overused strategy.
Scamming wouldn’t work either, most people already realized that those games grants no salary, nor ever does big giveaways.

You need to understand why your game is better. Precisely, logically. Compared to other cafes.
If it’s the map, then you should make the ad a shot of your map.
If it’s the food, then you should make the ad a gallery of foods.
If it’s nothing, then what can you show? See?

That’s my point.
Be honest!

That’s not accurate, but I did get a good laugh out of your post.

In all seriousness, try some spending more on ads. A successful campaign will probably cost around 25K-100K Robux.

As most people have said here, noting that I’m late to the party, your ad campaign is minor compared to some of the massive campaigns presented by groups like Vikinglaw’s Soviet Union and major cafe/hotels.

Present a graphic people can relate to. If they feel connected to it they may display an interest in your group specifically. There are hundreds upon hundreds of groups in this genre, and they will always compete technologically, marketing wise and in members.

While this guy has made a show of himself already, this point does still stand. In order to pay developers, get a group off the ground and run advertisements, it can slowly add up to major sums. In a lot of cases, groups flop simply because of a lack of funding.

Case in point, it’s likely the best option to make yourself stand out. Do something bold or revolutionizing that makes you different or you’ll get carried away in the trend that is the restaurant community.

And in general the ad is the most generic crap I’ve ever seen. Rich avatars in cafe game ads. They’re all the same.

1 Like

There is also a ton of games like that they are also generic. It’s a big ocean and one very small fish.

1 Like

At this genre of the group/game, you get less to almost no members in your group if you advertise. People find cafe games no fun.

NO one would ever spend that much on a cafe game ad, because they would never bring revenue back. lmaooo

2 Likes

I agree they are definitely an overused monopoly.

1 Like

To give you a tip, @sadieseeds, take advice from @SovietsDevEx .
Cafe games get boring over time.
They have barely any room for events, and are just a cringe idea in general.
It’s like a tycoon, except way less fun.

Try to make games that have action in them, good choice is Melee Combat and FPS genres.