Marina Bay - Feedback

Hello fellow developers, I need some comments to further improve this project!


Game is still heavily under-development, and many buildings are not completed yet!

It is meant to look like the real-life Marina Bay in Singapore!

Feedback will gladly be appreciated! :smiley:

18 Likes

It looks amazing bro. Each and every small detail. And it definitely looks like Marina Bay.
Maybe you could make this game into a GTA style game. Imagine how much more detailed this game would be.

4 Likes

Wow! It is great all the small details are there, although one key things to having the best builds is good lighting. Keep up the good work you are going places.

2 Likes

Looks amazing imo. Haven’t seen any marina bay on roblox that is as nice as this

2 Likes

If you removed all of the Roblox UI, I’m sure some people would believe these screenshots are real. I do agree with @Nanoswamp, the incredible lighting does play a major role in creating a beatiful environment.
Please, please, please, keep us updated!

3 Likes

The building so far looks great, I almost thought it was real for a second there…!

What you can do is reduce the light ray Intensity because just looking at it hurts my eyes. Also, it will improve game visibility and performance on lower-end devices (as the GPU is not drawing as much).

Again with the light rays-
They don’t colour match with the reflectance off the road:

Here, you see a yellow-ish colour
image
Here, you see a bright, blueish white:
image

Colour matching and fine-tuning these light rays’ll add a little bit more to your game.
As Blender Guru said, it’s the little things that matter.

Thanks for reading!

2 Likes

This is looking great so far! If I didn’t have prior knowledge, I would have thought this wasn’t in roblox. I love the attention to detail and lighting. Try working on the soundscape to add that extra layer of immersion. Adding that extra ambiance would add a lot to the world. Hoping to check it out soon, great work!

2 Likes

I love seeing these open-world city/town games in Roblox, especially one with such impressive detail and one that mimics the real-life city as well as this does. I’d suggest ensuring buildings are properly optimized ensuring that they use the minimum amount of parts as possible. If this isn’t done, most lower-end PCs won’t be able to handle the (potentially, if not optimized) high part counts around the cluster of skyscrapers.

I think the project is off to a great start, any additions I would suggest I presume would be added (or added more of, such as a focus on greenery with as much emphasis as buildings.) I would recommend using a texture for the road to go along with the realism you are going for. Great work so far, to you and your team.

3 Likes

You accomplished your sense of scale nicely, well done! I just may suggest adding details around the ground and external details, as those will be the most visible to players.

2 Likes

We have a development/community Discord if you guys are interested :slight_smile:

@MrFunnyLucky

1 Like

Those buildings are really nice and make a great view for some in-game screenshots. As you build along i suggest adding some more detail here and there, e.g. traffic cones on the streets, litter, loose leaves around trees, things of this sort.

2 Likes

The building is very nice :slight_smile:. Tbh you should try adding more stuff littler on te sidewalks but that’s my thought keep going bro

1 Like