Mouse Button Down and Up Firing Remote Events weird

Help and Feedback Scripting Support
#1 
local isActive = false
function main()
	getCowButton.MouseButton1Down:Connect(function()
		print('Down Triggered')
		isActive = true
		GetCowModule.mouseButton1Down(player)
	end)

	player:GetMouse().Button1Up:Connect(function() --Had to do getmouse because glitch where you move cursor off of button and it still fired event
		print("Up Triggered")
		if isActive then
			print("Inside")
			GetCowModule.mouseButton1Up(player)
			isActive = false
		end
	end)
	
	ShopHandler.main(player)
end

This code is pretty buggy. When I hold down on the button then lift up, it will stay active. If I hold down on the button then move off of the button then lift, then it will not be active (this is what i want), but if I hold down on the button then move to a different GUI then lift up then it will stay active. Why is this happening and how can I fix it?

#2

Are you saying that if the mouse moves to a different button while down, it should activate the new one and not the old one? In that case it would be simpler to only detect when the mouse goes up.

#3

Nah so like theres only one button, but if you press down on that button and move to any different gui (whether its a frame, label, button, etc) it will not detect when mousebutton up for some reason

#4

I got nothing for that. It seems like one of those Roblox quirks. Is there any reason not to just detect if a button is unclicked on, and forego the down part?

#5

Idk what that question is asking. This feature of my game is basically that as long as youre holding down starting on that button, you will gain a stat until you release ur mouse. This means it doesnt matter where ur mouse ends up, it needs to stop once you release it.

#6

Oh, I thought it was just a normal button. Do the other GUI elements have Interactable disabled? If that doesn’t work, you could try using UserInputService:IsMouseButtonPressed(), but that needs to be checked every frame.