Need feedback for square tumbnail

I notice that people don’t click my current game as much as my other games when I advertise it.
I figured my current square thumbnail is too noob-ish

I made a new one. Personally I think its at least better.
Normally I don’t ask feedback.
But please. Tell me how I could improve this new thumbnail.

I am very new to making these things.
Any help would be awesome.

Notice: I dont tell you what the game is about. Because this picture must show that.
Does this picture show what the character is?

Old picture
whale icon 400 x400 final

New one (need feedback on this one)

Not going to lie, the second one looks a bit too bland. Maybe add more things in the background? Also, you could render the whale in blender and if you don’t know how to, here is a tutorial I found on youtube on how to make gfx: HOW TO MAKE ROBLOX GFX (BLENDER 2.79) | In-depth Tutorial - YouTube

1 Like

Thank you! Great video for me.
It seems I have much to learn.
I knew nothing from what they show in this video.

1 Like

The second shark needs more improvement, maybe add more features to it

1 Like

Personally, I prefer the first one. I don’t know how you can improve the second one though, maybe make it less… happy?

Its a whale. Lol. Welp. Come on. :upside_down_face: