Need Honest Advice to Improve My Soccer Game (10k Robux Invested in Ads)

Help and Feedback Creations Feedback
1

Hey everyone

I’ve been working on a soccer-style Roblox game for a while, inspired by the big football titles on the platform.
I’ve already spent around 10,000 Robux on ads + sponsorships, but I’m noticing the game still struggles to reach new players or retain them.

I’d love to get genuine feedback from experienced developers or game designers on what might be missing whether it’s:

  • The core gameplay loop (ball physics, movement feel, camera, etc.)
  • The UI / first-time experience
  • Player retention / replay value
  • Or if I should simply invest more in marketing and visibility

I’m open to constructive criticism , both on the design and business side.
My main goal is to make this one of the top soccer games on Roblox, not just rely on ads.

Here’s the game link:
:backhand_index_pointing_right: Astro Soccer - Roblox

If you can, please let me know:

  1. What was your first impression when joining?
  2. What felt off or confusing?
  3. Would you play again if it had new features or better polish?

I’m super grateful for any insights, and I’m open to collaborations or consultations if someone specializes in game design / balancing for sports experiences.

image
image1402×728 60.1 KB

image
image1376×714 83.9 KB

Thanks a ton for reading :folded_hands:

2

Still didn’t try the game, but i see that you need to try and improve and the day 7 retention as it is super important, on the other side you should add some monetization too as it could be the reason your game not performing well..

3

I have 2 stores, a vip gamepass and a store for crates, my main issue rn is the lack of players

4

Nitpick, volume is loud

Issue, can’t play the game if there aren’t other players also playing. Well there is the practice mode, but it’s a bit hidden, and not very engaging