New icon for an FPS game

[Mind_Bind]

I just somewhat finished up some work on a new icon for an FPS game I’m working on that is basically like CSGO/Valorant without agents.

This is what I cooked up:

What are your suggestions/feedback? And what icon do you find better (i think the poll results are gonna be obvious)

• Icon #1 (with the bad guy)
• Icon #2 (with the soldier)

(" ¹ " means some people disagree)
I already got:

• make the red into an orange¹
• get rid of unnecessary stripes¹
• make title a bit more readable
• change title font and color

[ProfessorDevAlt (DontPlayWitMe)]

first the font is not bad but i would change and second is the background doesn’t match with FPS it matches more like a simulator game.

[agentphilip07 (Philip)]

This FPS game icon looks good. The suggestions you already got are good, except I think the blue and red are good colors, there’s no need to change it to orange. Nice job on this icon!

[baseparts]

Lools great! It might just be me, but I think the title feels a little out of place. Maybe try messing around with its font and color

@Mind_Bind

• make the red into an orange
• get rid of unnecessary stripes

I disagree with these, I like the red and blue and I think you should keep the stripes.

[Mind_Bind]

OK I kinda went for that ESport-sy and Paintball-y type of icon. I got mainly inspired by these images:

(Counter Strike 2 image, and random Paintball poster)

[Mind_Bind]

I was also kinda hesitant on whether I would like to change the red to orange but it’s feedback after all.