Please give me feedback on my thumbnail and icon

Hello, could you please give me some feedback on these! Also, please let me know how well I did out of 10, thank you.

1 Like


They have detail and are eye catching.Excellent. I would give it a 9/10.

Have a great day/night!


Thank you for the feedback! :slight_smile:


Absolutely amazing, I love the amount of detail on the players and their tools. Added to this the both images are high quality - I hope you’re getting paid generously for this. 10/10

1 Like

I love them, i love the lighting, i love the terrain, i love everything!
I would definetely give this a 9/10!

1 Like

I’d boost the hue and or saturation up a bit.

Hi @zufyre,

I’d probably give them a 6/10. There is a few errors I have found that may detract the effect (from me at least). For the icon, I believe the sun glaring is way too powerful and bright in the logo. It may detract from the fact it is a crafting game. Secondly, with everyone so serious, the fox, who is smiling definitely does not fit in with the logo. The skin of the crafters make them look artificial. I do not know if this is intentional, but they appear to be glossy and also doll-like. There is also some shadow issues.

What program did you use to make these? They are great otherwise.