Okay maybe I’m a little late to the party but I’ll throw in my opinion to the mix.
The idea of free speech is not recognized in most places - in fact, if you consider hate speech as a part of speech, I’m pretty sure there are laws against hurtful or inappropriate speech. And more often than not, as many Post Approval members and other DevForum people have mentioned, there are tenets and guidelines that we agree to when we sign up for the DevForum, or any organizational setting. This is how life works, we are not all barbarians and most people agree that chaos is not a good model for how we should live out our lives. The moderators here have all the power that is given to them to do what they wish with said power. If they can edit posts, hoorah. If they can change the wording of your title, then there isn’t much in our own power we can do, except, you know, re-editing.
But I agree with Soybeen.
Look, Roblox is not a communist organization. Sure we sign to give them the rights for many things we do on the website, and this is like any organization that provides the user with an interface such as this. But we have some say in what goes, and what doesn’t. We are the developers, without us Roblox can’t thrive the way it does now. And it’s nice to see that we are able to communicate on issues we disagree with in the first place; very few organizations will allow low-level members to negotiate and discuss the guidelines on which the organization is built. So we have a lot going for us and I think we should consider that as a huge benefit. And I think I’ll reiterate for the amount of times Soybeen has tried to make this clear, this is outside the issue that was brought up. We already know these things, and we are grateful for the opportunity we get to act on issues we have.
All we want is for our own words to be left alone - and I think this is substantial. This is really important and anyone who has studied a second language will know that meaning can easily get lost in translation. And perhaps the forum here is in English, but as you might find in this thread, not everyone is a native English speaker. And there are some younger folks probably who have less experience using fancy lingo or are unaware of how to concisely form their title to propagate their message. It seems that this is one of the main points people on this thread keep bringing up - these “harder to find” titles or “difficult to understand” or “conveys the wrong meaning” phrases are detrimental to the forum functioning properly. That they cause latency in finding a correct reply and in searching for existing threads.
But that is not an excuse to reform the title, even if the intention was to keep the sanctity of the original meaning and make it clearer for other users. This is washing away our identity and it is actually a form of censorship that is not acceptable in many, almost all, dare I say, organizations. Soybeen requested that there should be a feature that notifies users that this title is not the original author’s title. I don’t see the difficulty in doing this, not at all. We have terrain generation, UIGradients and advanced materials and lighting - is it that difficult to implement something like this? Correct me if I’m wrong, but I’m pretty sure the big up-and-coming features in Studio completely blow away the work that it would take to add in a little editor notice.
And if you feel confused at this point because I said Roblox can do whatever they want, I’ll reiterate again that WE have a say in what works and what doesn’t. We don’t have to be blind to whatever the guidelines may be and we can definitely improve upon what already exists. I’ve seen some arguments saying that we should follow rules and guidelines, but I want to remind those of you who believe so - who came up with these rules? What makes them fundamentally right? Roblox doesn’t have a monopoly on what is right or wrong, and they acknowledge this by letting us discuss what should and shouldn’t be allowed on their site. We have a right to voice our opinion. If our words get changed, then it is common practice that an editor is attributed to said post.
That is what we are asking for here. And I’m not going to repeat the many suggestions that have been given for applying a system like this or functionally similar, there are many. Even if there are folks here who “trust” the moderators, not everyone knows them personally and not everyone can blindly trust others on the internet to understand their intentions. If you want to relabel what we say in our titles, just add a little tick saying you guys edited it. It really isn’t that difficult.
For those interested, I haven’t actually written a post or title, so if that takes away from what I said, I don’t mind but really this reply I’ve made is just a summary of what I have read from the opinions here with a little bit of my own thrown in.