Hi! I made a gfx design for a friend of mine, mind giving feedback?
The word SchwarzWalde will go away, just ignore it.
There is some grain effect, its suppposed to be there, its not low quality.
Is this good enough for a clothing group?
0 voters
What would you rate it out of 10?
0 voters
This GFX looks really nice for a group logo, that’s why I said yes.
I only rated it a 6/10 because roblox has a really young audience. If a 7 year old saw the group, they would skip over it (since kids judge a book by its cover) because it looks to “old fashion” and it may not catch their eye as per say another group would catch their eye. That’s why I rated it a 6/10.
The tv 
looks a bit stretched out and distorted. I know it’s hard to fix that, but if you can, it would make it look much better. Also add a backround because just 1 avatar and a tan background doesn’t seem realistic. Maybe add trees or something tropic in the background so the character doesn’t seem bland. Here is a logo for a clothing group I’m starting up.
To answer your question, yes it is good enough. Just add more to it.
Good luck!
Thank you very much for the detailed response, but I can’t do anything about the tv, and I might just render an entire scene where the characters sitting down at a news station, so it gives G-Eazy vibes. I don’t really care if the logo looks “old-fashion” because the ad will be bright to catch eyes and attention. 
Thank you for your time!
I can see the design you’re going for, but the TV looks very stretched along with the resolution isn’t the best.
Hi @SchwarzWalde! The font for your breaking news looks a little odd. In addition to this the red block on the top looks very small. (Didn’t really understand if you could change these, though).
For your actual gfx, I would say it looks great, though the background color looks a little too dark (I would recommend something slightly brighter).
