Rate my new map!

Hello I changed my map based on past feedbacks. Here is old map and new map :

Old map

old1
old2

New map


Which one looks better?
  • Smooth plastic style (Low poly - ish)
  • With materials and detailed trees
  • I have better option ( Please write your feedback in comments )

0 voters

So please write your feedbacks in this topic.

2 Likes

In my opinion i think the materialised map looks great, it really brings some of the assest to life by giving them more detail.

Nice building style by the way, looks cool!

2 Likes

I like the new map more! With material it looks more detailed and the colors are not so bright. But if you use material, the rest of the objects (e.g. in build mode) should also match…

1 Like

Your old map was better in my opinion.

Your map gives the vibe of smooth plastic style low pol , so the original materials and trees fit in.

The new trees and materials you’ve added sorta give off a different kind of map vibe. Like a more realistic one.

It depends on the game you’re making and it’s genre, but I think by the UI alone a more smooth plastic low poly map would fit in.

2 Likes

So, I’m making advanced tycoon or unique style factory grinding game (As you can see there is grid placement baseplates for factory) , not a generic style simulator, I think the new map fit for my game but if you think the old one is better yet let me know why. Thanks for sharing your opinion.

2 Likes

I just thought personally that for a simulator styled game, even if not generic. Low poly maps usually fit in, plus you’d probably get more players because of kids if you want that.

Then again, i’m not a builder/modeller. But this is just what I think.

2 Likes

All of these maps look great! Nice job on it! I think that with materials and trees is the best! How long did it take to build this map? It’s cool!

2 Likes

5 days character limit