Roblox GFX Blender | Which one is better - Cycles or Eevee Render Engine?

So, I’ve been experimenting on Blender with the two render engines and I really don’t know what to stick with. Here’s the pro’s and con’s of what I feel makes this a hard decision.

Cycles:
Pros: Good lighting and shadows formed, overall giving it a realistic effect.
Cons: Sometimes too bright (e.g example below) + takes forever to render (24 minutes for the simple photo below)
Evee:
Pros: Good on lowpoly builds and has a lot more features than Cycles (e.g Emission) + fast rendering.
Cons: Most likely to have the worse lighting and shading meaning I have to use 3 point lighting + a HRDI (or a sun light)

Here’s the same render but with the two different engines:

Cyles:

Eevee:

Ignore how bad the render and texture is, this was a quick job to ask for support - not seeking for feedback on this 10 minute render - I also used a terrible HRDI

Which one pops more or is better to use?

  • Eevee’s Render Engine
  • Cycle’s Render Engine

0 voters

It would be more helpful if you told me the reason why the specific render engine is better.

3 Likes

The second one looks really better because not only does people I’ve seen in the graphics community using that but it also fits everything such as the scene much better. Sure cycle render can be a realistic way, but it’s sometimes too bright. My thought is the 2nd one, Eevee.

1 Like

You can configure the brightness for Cycles and it will look 100x better. He was probably making the lighting in Eevee and that’s why it looks bad in Cycles.

2 Likes

I didn’t do anything with the lighting. It’s a HRDI and all I did was simply switch the engines then rendered.

I’d mess around with your HDRI, it’s way too bright. For the highest quality render, Cycles will always be better. For a quick render, Eevee suffices, but the lighting will not look nearly as good.

I wasn’t bothering with the GFX. I just downloaded some random HRDI for an example.

Well you need to bother with the GFX for a nicer result with Cycles then.

It was an example, but I’m just asking for what engine is better - not entirely based on the photos.

Cycles render engine is more powerful than evee, I only use cycle if I am taking a render of a single model and not a scenery because it takes a lot of time for it to render, I’ve mostly used evee for GFX, with good lightning and textures it looks decent. If you want to render something quick or want to get an idea of how it will look in cycles use evee.

1 Like

This is super bright! I like cycles, but definitely tone down the lighting.

Okay, but that was already mentioned lol.

Cycles is defintely the one if you want good looking lighting w/ shadows and reflections/so on. Here are some example renders I do (I’m a little lazy to link them :pensive:)

Look in “SHOWCASE” and you’ll find the renders :+1:

Eevee should be only used if you’re looking for a quick render for a test OR you don’t really care that much about shadows and small details.

Cycles = More better lighting/slow
Eevee = Okay lighting/fast/quick tests

Plus, you can defintely speed up render times. Just slap on some denoise nodes, turn down samples, lights, etc. Doing these steps mostly takes me 10 minutes on more expensive renders (at times though)

Also I’m very glad you didn’t restrict the poll to artists only, thank you :+1:

Another thing, you can utilize composition to get glow on glowing objects. Works perfectly fine and is MUCH more customizable imo.

1 Like