I’ve been working on some thumbnails for myself, I created these designs (Took me about 2h) to make all of them, and I had to modify a lot of the rigs I used to fit in. But now I need feedback on the design should I put Guns in thumbnails? Everything here is rendered in cycles 5K.,
Server Banner:
Thumbnail:
Criticisms welcomed!
Looks good but I am not a fan of the characters and that there being no background and how the characters are posed. The last one is the best one so far though. But still needs some sort of backgrond and the characters needs to be better. I would give it a
35 lemons out of 100 limes.
Thanks for the feedback. This is helpful. 
Haven’t worked on GFX for a while lol, I’ll do better next time.
Key Lime Pie my dude, I like the ratting choice friend!
Looks really good! i love the characters, except for the shoulder pads look like they do not have any material (they look a bit too smooth maybe?)
Another point i have is that there is not much of a background/scene (not sure if this is about the characters or if you also want feedback on the composition)
Also you could make the poses tell a story… It could add an extra dimension to the characters if you know what i mean.
Ya you’re right, I’ll change it thanks.
I’ve personally always hated that face type since I first saw it, and its still as terrible as I remember.
Backgrounds are non-existent, but the general quality of the images is high.
Can’t say the same for posing though, mainly on the second image.
The character is holding what appears to be a minigun. From the barrels. That spin. You should not hold a minigun, or any gun for that matter by the barrel.
(I know nothing about gun safety as I am Australian, do not quote me on this)
Then theres the clash of the kinda low-poly weapons with flat textures and the detailed textures and models for the military armor.
Overall, its alright, has its issues. The faces are my biggest problem, but its purely because I personally despise them, they look terrible to me and there is no way to make them good.
Overall I’d give it 5.5/10. Good quality, some issues.
