Severe DMCA Moderation Mistake

Hello developers,

I was recently victim to a very unjustified account termination, which left me and fellow developers unable to access the game’s revenue causing us to lose 5000+ euros in devex robux.

Game: MEGA Boss Survival - Roblox
Group: Anti-Boredom - Roblox

I was banned for the DMCA Repeat Infringer Policy, which means i was striked multiple times for creating multiple “copyrighted” assets on the platform. However, in my case these strikes and also ban, were completely ridiculous.

For starters, the assets i was striked for were no longer owned by me. Back in 2018-2019 i created a bunch of random T-shirts with images like: spongebob, marshmellow, etc inside various groups.
These groups, i had already lost ownership to and left years ago which left me completely unattached to any of these assets.
(This ofcourse, when i was a bit younger and had no knowledge of anything copyright related, which a kid can’t be blamed for and so should not be so heavily penalized without consideration)

But that isn’t the only issue though, roblox claim to have sent a moderation notice to me to check my account for potential copyrighted assets and send them over. I never saw this moderation notice and found out they sent it via roblox messages, which is an awful choice of communication for such a serious issue. A moderation notice via mail would’ve been much better and that i would’ve seen.

In my opinion and the opinions of everyone i’ve discussed this with (friends, other developers, …) this ban is completely ridiculous.
Roblox is responsible for not communicating correctly that assets i no longer owned could affect my account aswell as not contacting me properly about any impending moderation issue.

And as you might expect i contacted support for this multiple times. Unfortunately they didn’t understand my situation as they kept responding with the same answer mentioning i was sent a moderation notice. (Even though they never sent me any moderation notice appropriately). I even called them, which was also met with no response.

I also contacted them after getting banned, with 30+ links of possible copyrighted items, which was met with a response completely ignoring all the links, saying i was justifiably banned even though that had nothing to do with what i sent?

Taking all this into consideration, how can one consider this ban justified? And why should a person be punished this way, without receiving proper communcation on roblox’s end that any issue was nearing?

Considering a loss of 5000+ euros is involved in this, i feel like i definitely deserve a proper way of communcation + response. My first appeal already explained everything deeply, considering it was denied it is apparent it was a robot that looked over my appeal. Severe issues like this should not be looked upon by robots!

I’d love to hear some people’s opinions about this, i know i shouldn’t post this here really, but what options do i have left other than going public with this? Roblox has made it so hard to contact them about these severe issues that all i can do now is hope this will gain attention.

4 Likes

My main’s been terminated since October of last year for the same issue. Repeat Infringement. It makes matters worse when you realize that they just recently added a feature to REQUEST to have this content removed in the first place. They say that these warnings werent heeded but there was no proper way to do so.

Classic clothing has always been a risk for DMCA whether it’s valid or not, and to make matters worse im pretty sure they should be giving people a CHANCE to remove the content instead of outright terminating people. It’s frustrating and feels shady as all heck considering that if it was a well known content creator on Roblox they would be unterminated within an instant, but for the lesser known users and developers they just cast their moderation issues to the wayside.

I hope a staff member sees this and solves your issues, or at least gives some sort of context to them, as this has gone on for far too long.

1 Like