Should a semi old Roblox type game have guns?

Help and Feedback Creations Feedback
,
#1

Hello I have this game I’m working on and I’m split on adding guns or not. So far this is most the weapons in the game right now:

  • Sword
  • Trowel
  • Paintball gun (using fe gun kit)
  • Rocket Launcher (using fe gun kit)
  • Airstrike
  • Superball
  • Melee type gears
  • Coil gears
  • Different explosive gears
  • Slingshot (using fe gun kit)
  • Flamethrower
  • Healing gears
  • Trap gears

My map so far

RobloxScreenShot20231227_130038737
RobloxScreenShot20231227_1300387371382×810 52.8 KB

RobloxScreenShot20231227_130034389
RobloxScreenShot20231227_1300343891382×810 50.2 KB

I feel like adding a shotgun and some SMG’s might fit if do the style and pricing right but I don’t know if I should add AK’s, m4a1, snipers, pistols. Should I have a little bit of guns? No guns? A bunch of guns?
Please let me know!

3 Likes
#2

A gun back then was just a brick that threw little balls at people that do damage.

2 Likes
#3

lets not forget the gears like the trench shotgun, luger, revolver, and garand. He seems to be going for a 2014 style with the coins and they fit.

#5

Hey! I think all of those guns fit. The only ones that don’t fit really good (In my opinion) are the Flamethrower and the Airstrike. I think those ones are a bit “exaggerated” for a classic game. OK a classic game can work really good with those guns but I think that all of your guns can fit if you keep them simple. A classic game has simple things, and that’s what makes them look classic. (Oh and also, your game looks really good I hope you can finish it :+1:)

I posted the same post but I replied to @Uhfk by accident and the DevForum doesn’t let me post the same what I posted before, don’t mind this LOL

2 Likes
#6

Sorry this is a late response but I agree with you and thank you for your opinion!