i have a game called “Survive the crazy” , i released this game June 2023 and i have been updating it this whole year hoping someday i see it popular , the problem is i start losing hope and thinking about it is a waste of time , the game is about survive a crazy who is a random player until the end of the round , players can gain coins to buy different items , this is the game idea , iam looking for your feedback about if it is a good game and deserve more updating or it is a bad game and deserve to die , this is the game link if u wanna try it :- 🔪Survive the crazy - Roblox
this forum is a complete of this forum :- Help me making my game successful - #16 by Mubinets
i really need your feedback i will be thankful if you give me your feedback.
Well what makes your game Unique? What separates your game from others? Imagine being in a job. Everyone has the same role maybe different departments (Same Game Idea, Different Designs) and then theres the Manager who stands out (Being what makes your game better than the other)
Glad to see that you are considering my feedback, however, I’d like to give you something to think about.
So as for your question, whether to let your game die or not. That depends completely on the motivation of you making the game. Why did you make it? Is it that you loved horror game? Or are you just doing it for money?
You might not be able to make a high quality game, but you can always re-master it. Focus on improving your skills first (UI, Music, Modelling, Building). You must always LEARN from your mistakes. If your game wasn’t successful, you would need to understand why it wasn’t successful.
When you are more experienced, come back to your original passion which is for your horror games (if that’s so), you can re-make the game with better quality (remaster version). Your future game might succeed if you are more consistent.
Conclusion
If your game still has potential, improve yourself first then re-make the game to ensure that it reach it’s full potential.
Your game is not really failure, your game is rather just unpopular with over 1K views. It’s just poor-made, the only way you fail is if you give up entirely on that project (by focusing on the entire new different game). If you still improve your game, there is a higher chance that it will succeed.
If you love horror games, you are free to try making other games to learn more. And then you are free to come back to remaster your old game.
UI is pretty decent. Maybe fix the top bar it seems too big.
The Map voting system is pretty good.
Game takes too long to start, especially choosing the “Crazy”
– Playing the game now
Maybe work on a custom UI for the knife
The text at the top is still too big.
After Thoughts:
Game has many spelling errors, Killer should get custom knives that have special ability example (10% Damage but -5% Walk Speed). This gives the survivors a sense of trusting people. Maybe redo the UI, it seems a bit cluttered some organization could be better. The maps are pretty good for a start. A little more detail would be nice like on the walls or broken boxes. Thinking about it now. Maybe the crazy can break the boxes and search them for a boost. Like Break a box. The box holds a liquid. Then Crazy consume liquid and gets this rush of adrenaline.
The crouch button is too weirdly placed on the screen. maybe bottom corner could be better
But i really think this game has potential. Don’t be afraid to rework your game’s code to polish it.
Last opinion, drop it for a bit. Work on a fun little side project then come back to either polish it or rebuild it.
