I’d like your personal opinion on the game icon and on how it can be improved:
18 Likes
Very good! A lot of people make icons too complex in detail and they end up under thinking the simplistic aspect of icons. They are small. As detailed as it is, no one will see it at the size. You did not have that problem that much, but maybe scale the background image up a little so its easier to see the characters.
2 Likes
I can tell that you’ve spent a lot of time working on this logo! However, I do have a couple suggestions on things you can change.
First is what @Sentross had said earlier: you need to provide less detail in your icon. I think the maximum size of an icon before quality disappears is 500 by 500 pixels, and I’m judging yours is probably 2000 at most. I recommend using the knights in the game’s thumbnail so players can see them in better detail.
My second suggestion is either lowering or removing the blurred colors on top of the words. Again, the icon will be sized down, so it may or may not make the game name harder to see (you can check it if you want.
Overall, I give this icon a 7.5/10. The detail and lighting is amazing, and it seems you have a pretty good understanding of the color theory. Great work!
1 Like
Thank you for the advice, i’ll get to work as soon as i can
Thank you for your advice also, i appreciate it. I’ll fix up the blur over the text asap. Thanks again 
I don’t really have much experience with graphic design, and am still learning a lot in this area. I just wanted to take the time to say how impressive and difficult this is to master! Nice job with this design.
I appreciate the compliment, and I wish you good luck on your journey to learn. you’ll do great
Very cool in all honesty!
The color stands out a lot, the figures, and everything! Even the black background looks quite fitting for this logo. Very well done.
1 Like
This is neat! I love how the character renders stand out. This makes me want to play the game. Keep up the great work. 
It is very well done and managed, for one thing.
I highly advise that you enlarge your figures quite a bit, as they would be quite difficult to see as an icon. Or, simply remove two of them and enlarge your favourite figure to cover most of the image.
The text looks blurry, even though that was intentional on your part. However, I suggest that for a more “pop” effect that can catch the eye, you keep things as clear and as bright as possible.
Good contrast however, which really helps!
Ignore the misinformation about scaling the icon down. Icons are 1080x1080 on Xbox. Keep the detail.
1 Like
Its actually really good, but i would change the color of the 3rd knight, it just doesent fit imo. Anyways good work and keep up your doings 
I like everything except the text. It seems to me that the orange text is too dull and simple with respect to everything else. I would advise making the text bigger and brighter. And so, I really like it!
It looks too bright in my opinion, too many colors that don’t really match. Also, since it’s about knights, i’d use a more medieval-ish font
Too much outer glow, it can make the text seem blurry, especially for a game icon. Nevertheless, it is well done, however, the text can appear a bit too small.
Think you should zoom in on the center guy, it’s gonna be a small icon on the frontpage.
Something like this is more eyecatching imo.
1 Like