I cannot wait to see a new batch of UGC creators the ones we have right now are starting to get boring.
6 Likes
Can UGC creators publish under a group like clothing or such?
6 Likes
Well; whatever system is implemented, it needs to be something that isn’t 100% open. Maybe there should at least be a bit of an application process.
I’m just nervous about a completely open system.
Also, do you think this would lead to “race to the bottom” pricing like what happened to clothing?
Right now UGC items are pretty much averaging R100 in price. Do you think the prices would drop to pennies because of competition? Surely Roblox themselves wouldn’t want this because then their 30% cut would be worthless.
5 Likes
I definitely do not think it should be open to everyone as well as possibly some restrictions and guidelines. There should be an extensive application process and could possibly rotate modelers in batches to prevent over flooding the market. Though this would be pretty difficult to manage on a large scale. This is very interesting for Roblox to even be considering this. There’s no question that items will lose value, even if it is restricted to a group of people; unless there are heavy restrictions to what they can and cant make. Which could be possible. However, eventually there could be overlap due too lack of ideas.
Only time will tell I guess, I’m really curious to see the outcome of the UGC.
4 Likes
I would like to create objects for him UGC but I would like to know if that is because I have to rank up …
3 Likes
maybe later, but probably not now currently as i never have seen someone upload a ugc hat to the catalog. if the ugc catalog ever goes public, i hope its always locked to premium users as there would probably be less people copying.
3 Likes
Roblox might have a different plan than what you’ve stated. Who knows? 
2 Likes
What a surprise… I’ve been saying this since day 1, UGC is a mistake
#RemoveUGC
#CancelUGC
7 Likes
Wow someone actually agrees with me for once.
4 Likes
https://gyazo.com/7a6dd3da802dcf3b7af4ff9b229e4cb7
another gif to show that this UGC item stole graphics from a limited item.
https://www.roblox.com/catalog/5829845327/Cursed-Reapers-Mask
https://www.roblox.com/catalog/16722419/Red-Fang
Get better moderation staff that actually know what items already exist
#RemoveUGC
9 Likes
Instead of trying to plague roblox with cancel culture how about trying to give suggestions on how they can improve UGC.
Also hate to break it to ya but there’s not enough evidence for copying. Red angry eyes are an idea which can’t be copyrighted. Besides they don’t exactly line up. Both in size and angle.
On a side note why do you only come here to complain about UGC?
So far the only valid cases I’ve seen are the bird, the 1
butterfly and stolen art. Can we please keep this civil and refrain from grasping at straws.
11 Likes
This is just grasping at straws lol… there’s much better examples of items looking similar to Roblox items.
And at the end of it, we see upwards of ~100 hats a week. It’s very apparent that at some point these things are going to happen, given the amount of catalogue we’re recieving
5 Likes
I love the UGC items on the catalog, however, does this mean Roblox is discontinuing their sales?
3 Likes
Considering they haven’t hosted a sale since President’s Day 2019… yes.
5 Likes
I’m aware of that, I just happened to see these items at the time.
3 Likes
And roblox made red angry eyes first?
The short answer is no. Red eyes have existed far longer than roblox. Personally I dont get why you only come on here to complain about items instead of provided insightful feedback.
If you feel some items should be removed then contact roblox.
Besides, if roblox would gave found any of these hats as a problem like you claim they are then they would have been removed. Yet they’re still up so clearly roblox is fine with it.
8 Likes
Personally until the Roblox UGC Catalog has some transparent path where developers other than their hand picked special snowflakes are able to participate in it then it’s just another Roblox elitist club I want no part of.
I understand there should be some screening but at it’s current rate Roblox is simply hand picking developers they want to give the opportunity to become successful while giving the rest of us the opportunity to either drool or help them get wealthy.
To me this catalog is nothing more than selling us until we are able to participate in it like an Amway or Essential Oils salesman.
Being as this is the same group lacking even the transparency to properly inform us on how to become full members after removing posting approval, which was trash anyway, I don’t trust this will be available to the rest of us anytime in the foreseeable future so it feels a lot like being sold a gamepass.
I joined the dev forum to develop and grow in developing, not to be sold.
25 Likes
Yeah, it’s happened a load of times and should be dealt with.
21 Likes