Update to Roblox Groups

The only person affected is @Telanthric

(skibidi toilet, ipad kids)

8 Likes

Roblox allows these games to stay up while their outsourced moderation contractors remove legitimate games with no accountability or realistic chances at appeal.

13 Likes

Communities won’t be available to users under 13. There are too many legal and regulatory hurdles to jump through. That’s why virtually no social media platforms allow under 13 users.

7 Likes

Not that it’s a good idea, but they seem to want to do it anyway.

7 Likes

Maybe if you cared about making your platform safer, you could hire more human moderators, instead of heavy over-reliance on ineffective AI moderation systems? According to a quick Google search, Roblox only employs around 1.5-2k human moderators, but has around 79.5 million daily active users as of Q2 2024. That’s approximately one human moderator for every 39-53 thousand users on Roblox. For comparison, Tiktok, another large platform, hires around 40,000 human moderators.

Bandaid, quick-fix solutions like this are just more of an inconvenience to users who might not be old enough to use Discord to give devs feedback on their games. How are <13 users supposed to give feedback/report bugs/suggest things now? Through private messages on the website? Oh wait, you recently removed those too because it was easier to just remove those than actually moderate scams in DMs.

16 Likes

This is a thoughtful, but bad update. Some people’s accounts are under 13 by accident. They want to change it to over 13, but they need an ID. Some people value their privacy, and don’t want to share their ID

13 Likes

Just curious, I noticed that these Roblox Communities (aka groups) features and Roblox Connect/Chat features have unintentionally been competitor to Guilded, a platform you guys own.

Will Roblox Communities and Roblox connect hurt Guilded’s future? And if not, what are plans for Guilded?

3 Likes

This is actually a good update. While to some, it may seem like simply blocking “free speech”, users below the age of 13 or those who have unverified accounts are the most likely to spam, spread misinformation, send scams or do any of that which harms players a lot more than not being able to speak.

7 Likes

I have no idea if this even prevents any inappropriate posting or not, as likely the people posting it are “13+” accounts.

6 Likes

These games stay up, while my game gets banned for ‘gambling’ even though it used a virtual currency that cannot be bought or traded for robux, had guaranteed wins each roll, and essentially was an rng game. great!

9 Likes

Wow… once again Roblox is removing critical features without any replacement. Sure, forums is coming in 3-6 months (or later because we all know how often features get delayed) but until then our players have zero means of communicating bug reports and feature requests and have no way to interact at all. What’s more is the group wall is FILTERED and easy to moderate if your community is set to manual approval (My 400k member group has been on manual approval for 8 years).

This change is detrimental to my community.

23 Likes

where OpenCloud api to rank people in a group

5 Likes

I agree strongly with this feature. I happen to be in management for a relatively large roblox group (50,000 members), and it’s interesting to see the contrast between the amount of users that contribute positively and negatively on group posts.


One one hand, you have someone begging for followers in hopes of being verified, but on the other hand you have a genuine and helpful request.
In conclusion, I don’t see the point for group walls at all for users under the age of 13. A tiny minority of people under the age of 13 will contribute positively - so why give them a platform at all. It makes the community safer in the respect that they can’t say anything… so how will they be in danger. Of course, I am only assuming that this user is under the age of 13, but it’s a pretty clear inference to make.

6 Likes

Open cloud ranking api plz :smiling_face: :smiling_face: :smiling_face: :smiling_face: :smiling_face: :smiling_face:

2 Likes

As much as I agree that we need to keep communities safe, I don’t think that limiting our features for 6+ months with a really buggy release of an alternative will help us. For crying out loud just let us ban users from groups or stop allowing special characters in wall posts :smiling_face_with_tear:

10 Likes

This is just shit. Like I’ve mentioned in other posts, I have a <13 friend who uses the group wall a lot (APPROPRIATELY), and now he is going to be limited along with millions of other users. Roblox this is becoming and IS unacceptable and is turning into a social media site.

19 Likes

This is bad for engagement. I used to ask my groups a “Question of the week” to increase engagement with the group and now a massive amount of my userbase can no longer answer the question of the week until the discussions feature comes out.

11 Likes

Minor improvements, but the platform will remain a hub for predatory behavior until you start terminating and HWID banning offending accounts no matter how much of the DAU they count towards. It is simply way too easy for offenders to come back again and again under new names. You have the tools for this already, start using them.

6 Likes

It is absolutely disgraceful that these games are being recommended to kids. Having them on the platform for children to seek out on their own is bad enough.

2 Likes

Honestly, if groups get a forums feature, with topics, threads, and polls, that would be insane. Developers could easily collect feedback and see public opinion without having to set up a Discord server or sort through loads of spam on the old walls.

However, there should also be an email verification requirement to prevent spam. (This could be configured by the group’s owner).

Overall this would be a great change.

2 Likes