VIP Server subscription failing?

Here’s a screenshot of what I saw when I configured my inactive (which it shouldn’t have been) VIP server for my own game, Lava Tumble.

It appears that the subscription fails to renew automatically, even when it is enabled to. I expect it to pay a 10 Robux fee from my account every 30 days instead of disabling my VIP server and making me go configure it again.

Symptoms/Potential causes (probably not this but maybe):
-The VIP server is for my own game
-I own more than one VIP server in my own game.

Here’s what it showed me when I clicked the “Subscription Status: Active” Button.