Weird Lighting Glitch Thing

So here’s the issue. The cardboard boxes look bright when I stand far away from them (notice the red circle down below).

But then as I get closer, they turn dark like they’re supposed to. I want a dark environment not a bright one (notice the blue circle down below).

How do I fix this issue? I have future lighting enabled and this issue only happens if the graphics level is 5 or higher.

The only thing that I can suggest is try changing the lighting mode to shadow map. Beyond that, I have no idea.