What game you would like to play more?

Help and Feedback Game Design Support
#1

Hello

I have little trouble with thinking good game idea. And I need help with picking the best from 3 ideas I thinked out today.

So the first idea, I like more is…

You spawn on little island (you own this island, and can’t sell it) on this island you need to survive and get some resources. Build your first shop and you can start the business! The main game’s idea is make your own business on little island, sell, trade e.t.c. and when you own a lot of coins, you can buy ship and explore or find new island, that you want to buy, to make your work faster & better you can hire workers (you will need to pay them). The customers will be NPCs, but real players can travel to your island (in special GUI) and purchase something. So this is the main things you can do. This game idea is mix of simulator, RPG and Role Play!

The second idea is…

Something like sword fighting, but way better. You don’t have shop, and that’s the problem! There will be dungeons, or something similar. So when you kill mob, coins and xp will drop from it. When you complete ~dungeon you get random reward - from just some coins, to item (e.g. sword or magic spell)! There will be trading too, but don’t think it would be that easy! You will need to pay fee, so you can give up to 3 items - fee for 1 item, will cost 50% of ~price of item. You can also trade coins, but 10% of coins will be fee. So idk, but there will be bosses, magic spells and much more I think.

Also

I have thinked about combining 1st idea with something from second, for example I can add bosses and mobs to 1st idea and PvP too.

Voting

Pick the best idea!
  • First idea
  • Second idea
  • First & Second ideas combined

0 voters

Note: Sorry for grammar mistakes, if there was and please don’t use/copy these ideas. (If they’re original lol)

3 Likes
#2

If there is one thing I don’t like, it’s when ppl copy ideas lol, anyways, I like the first idea, but if you can find a way to implement dungeons into the first, go for it, but it has to fit into the game you know, make it blend somehow.

2 Likes
#3

Yes, adding PvP into game where you create your business would not fit into the game. Umm maybe only missions, like find the crystal, in the cave. So this would give players coins and exp, plus adding some obstacles to make it more interesting.

1 Like