What style looks better?

Help and Feedback Creations Feedback
#1

Overview

Hello everyone, Kat here. I am here to ask you for opinions on some icons and thumbnails I designed for my project. Currently, my tester team is loving it but I don’t think it’s wrong to ask more people for opinions right?

Game Theme

The game is supposed to be a Story-Based FPS Heist Game. Kind of like entry point/payday 2 but also nothing like them as the story is pretty much extremely unique and such and I won’t go further down this rabbit hole.

Questions

Any who, these are my two icons and thumbnails. What I want to ask you people is:

Which style looks better?

How can I improve the most voted style?

Style 1 - Dark themed with 2 mercenaries. Shows the sad nature of the game.

Icon
Icon1080×1080 373 KB

Thumbnail2
Thumbnail21920×1080 57.2 KB

Style 2 - Red themed with 2 weapons. Shows the bloody nature of the game. (Also the OG icon/thumbnail for my game's legacy edition and such.

Icon
Icon512×512 255 KB

Thumbnail
Thumbnail1920×1080 1.46 MB

Poll

  • Style 1 looks best.
  • Style 2 looks best.

0 voters

If there are any issues with the style you like then please let me know down in the replies. I’ll be more than happy to fix them.

1 Like
#2

i accidentally voted for style 1 :fearful: i will never recover from this

1 Like
#3

Hmm personally I like the red one more, but I think that for whatever reason the first one looks more attractive. So maybe go with that

1 Like
#4

I agree with @FroDev1002, I usually love color, but for whatever reason I like the first one more. I really like the background texture for the first one, too (the graph-paper style thing).

2 Likes
#5

Too bad. I won’t be using the second one at all. :p

Thanks for appreciating my work. I will be going with the second one as my testing crew seems go like them quite a lot!

2 Likes
#6

I find the red one is more appealing and pops more.

2 Likes
#7

I guess I could have the red one for the demo version 2? And this for the demo version 1 then. Then make more for others bla bla bla.

1 Like
#8

old post but lemme say it

style 1 is the best

#9

Both of these styles look great! Good job on them! I’d say that the 2nd one is better since it doesn’t have the characters in the back, which fill it up a bit too much.

#10

first one is better imo, also why did you block me from testing game a while ago? i came back one day and you had blocked me and removed me from group, can i jsut know why?