Supergolf dominates any other attempt at a golf game as it is clean and enjoyable. Anyone can pick up the game and know what to do, with simple controls too.
The difference with actual golf is that it’s so much more difficult. The average Roblox player won’t know what clubs to use for different holes, lies, etc. I’ve been playing golf for many years and it’s definitely not for everyone, most people end up getting bored of it pretty quickly.
I think the only way to have a successful golf game on Roblox is to make it like Wii Golf. Have a choice of different courses, 3-holes (pitch + putt), 9-holes, and 18-holes.
You will need to make the club selection, swing etc simple but with advanced controls available to those who want it. For example, Wii Golf selected the ideal club for you but you still had that option to change it if you needed.
Personally I would love to see a proper golf game on Roblox, but I’m not sure how popular it would get.