What's the best icon for my game?

[EliottENAnnoucement (EliottENDevForum)]

So I have a choice of a few icons for my game Glove Fight (a fangame of Slap Battles), and I’d like to know what would be the best.

Icon 1

Icon 2

Icon 3

Icon 4

• Icon 1
• Icon 2
• Icon 3
• Icon 4

[CarlosmaniaLAPTOP (MightyFX)]

Ill have to say i like none

All very non telling and lacking identity,
theres no theme presented to us,
no calculated colour scheme
a lack of focal points

Either keep going with trying in graphics designing or hire someone else to do it for you; cant wait to see you in years; where you might be one of the best on the plattform!

Its a slow process getting good at graphics designing, but well worth it.

You begin to improve when you realize you need to.
SUCCESS TO YOU!

Regards ~ Carlos

[GalaxyGourmet]

I think #4 is the best, but I think it can be improved.

I’d bet it’d really look awesome if you made the glove bigger in #4, and maybe remove the text (to give space for the glove), because people should be able to see the glove clearly. That’s what the game is all about!

Looks pretty good though, good job!

[NoodleJam8000 (Snare)]

In my opinion, #4 is the best.

My reasoning:

• #1 is too bland, and the font’s a bit boring.
• In #2 the empty baseplate makes it seem less exciting, and the words glove and fight are kind of random. It obviously has something to do with your game, but it still seems kind of random in a way.
• #3 looks pretty good, but isn’t as exciting as #4.

Please know that I don’t mean these in a bad way; I’m only trying to give feedback. But besides this, these look great!