Add to profile and Remove from profile is the most terrifying way to organize stuff. Wanna move something to the front? Gotta remove every place, add it, then readd the places. Why isn’t there just a drag and drop for ordering places? I swear there used to be years ago.
Also this is subject to caching. I’ve heard of cases where it took over an hour to update. (no idea how)
It should be doing this if you haven’t touched the add/remove to profile buttons when this update was introduced, so you probably touched these in the past without realising what they did.
Actually I think ROBLOX tried to automatically add all games to their owners’ profiles but it didn’t work out exactly, because I doubt Shedletsky or the other people having problems with this accidentally clicked “Add to profile” on that many games.
Is this feature out of beta yet? I’ve had a rather interesting conversation with a random person on twitter and he was able to add/remove games from his profile as well. Maybe only people with beta access can do this?
We’ve all stopped complaining about it because they’ve made it extra clear that they aren’t going to change it, our opinions don’t matter in this issue
muh cross platform streamlining
muh unified aesthetic
muh google play store
Sounds like a bug. We will triage and fix asap. The button not being fully visible is rather not ideal, there are updates we originally planned that we can follow up with for that. As for the all the games should show up, here is my design question
If as a user, I create a new place, should it sit on top of my list in my profile page arbitrarily? Is the loop of just going to my profile and deleting the top spot every time I create a place a good process?
or
Every single game is added to your profile manually as chosen by you, better?
Let’s discuss. The overall way on how you add it to your profile might be the issue here.
I feel like every new game that is created should be added automatically. From there, we could use a drag and drop system to organize and (de)activate the places as we wish on the preferably redesigned Develop page.
Please note that this is counter to user expectations in the traditional way. I don’t expect an indirect action to cause stuff that i have carefully configured to shift. This is not the typical way things should work. There are always exceptions. Are you saying it’s an exception?
The button not working is a huge bug and has been reported and we will triage and fix.
[EDIT] The button seems to have a delay. I will measure and try to figure out why it’s slow tomorrow.
I prefer places to not be added to my profile unless I explicitly add them manually. Places I’ve just created aren’t playable – why should it be displayed on my profile? I also imagine it’d be especially annoying for people with OBC where 100 place creations later and oops they’re all on your profile and you get to have a fun time removing all but a handful of them. Manually adding places to the profile once they’re ready to be shown to the world, and never before, is good behavior.
I think the problem is that it’s not apparent enough why some places aren’t showing up on your profile, and that it’s not apparent how you can change that with Add/Remove to Profile. It’s not just a problem for those of us used to the old behavior either – new users won’t have a clue why no one else can see their places as well.