Which character GFX do you like better?

Help and Feedback Creations Feedback
,
#1

So I haven’t created any GFX in awhile so I created 2 of them in blender!
Which one do you think looks better? If any feedback on how I can improve them will be really nice!

1 VS 2
1 VS 2800×600 65.5 KB

I am planning on doing a scene as well!

6 Likes
#2

2 is better because it’s clearer. 1 is too dark so it’s harder to see. Maybe try 2 without the outline? That might look even better.

5 Likes
#3

Alright, thank you for the feedback!

1 Like
#4

2 but i’d make the outline brighter (dark grey or sth like that)

1 Like
#5

Thanks for the feedback! I’ll try it!

#6

both of them have things in which they aren’t great. for example, the second one has too bright lighting in some places, but character is not lit up at all. the posing is not great for that one too.

second one has not so great cel shading, the posing of the hand is weird, but the lighting is nice,

#7

2 is better. For first u must put light forward

#8

Both are great but they’re different styles, I think a mix would look best like what @Lightlimn said.

#9

Alrighty, thanks for the comment!

1 Like
#10

Thanks for the feedback on the GFX!

#11

Okay, thank you for the feedback!!

1 Like