Which icon looks more attractive?

[GetaLifeDrink]

So I have 2 game icons, 1 of which is really old but still looks decent and the other is new that I created a month ago

I also have winter versions of these icons, but they don’t look as attractive so they probably should be
discarded. What do you think about them?

[wonderbvy (saturn)]

very bottom IMO. good use of blur, color, lighting. Just looks more vivid and higher quality overall doesn’t have an old classic look to it.