Which inventory icon is better?

[luke9550 (luke)]

I recently redid the icons in my inventory and I don’t know if the old ones or the new ones are better so I’m just looking for some opinions

new:

old:

[TipsyAnthony (anthony)]

In my opinion; the new one is better, it fills up the space, and the background is about same as the one in the discover tab in the Roblox app, which gives it more “feeling”.

[ProvenData (John)]

The new one looks a lot better. Especially with how you made the border colors / random thicker. However I do have to say on the new UI that rounded square should become a rectangle and encompass the name and rarity too.